Skip to main content

The 8 best hot dog topping alternatives you need to try

Forget the mustard and sauerkraut, try these creative toppings instead

Three hot dogs with different topppings
Kajakiki / Getty Images

Summer will be here before we know it, so that means grilling season has almost arrived. Whether you have backyard barbecues, like to picnic at the barbecue pit in the park, or just want to harken back to your youth with hot dogs, why not get creative with some alternative hot dog toppings?

Our best alternative toppings for your dogs

You can prepare your hot dogs by steaming, boiling, or grilling, but that doesn’t mean the toppings have to be mustard only — and no, we don’t put ketchup on hot dogs. We’re going to take a look at some of the most creative hot dog toppings out there that are sure to up your hot dog game.

Recommended Videos

Classic Chicago dogs

The Chicago dog with poppy seed bun
@tigerrulezzz

These hot dog toppings always will be a staple. The Vienna Beef hot dog reached Chicago during the World’s Columbian Exposition in 1893, and the Chicago Dog was invented in 1929 at a stand named Fluky’s. The hot dog was originally called the Depression Sandwich. The Chicago-style dog features a poppy seed bun with an all-beef frank topped with mustard, white onions, dark green sweet pickle relish, sliced tomato, sport peppers, a dill pickle spear, and celery salt. If you don’t have the celery salt, that is passable, but you definitely can’t have a Chicago dog without the remaining ingredients.

New York dogs

A hot dog with white onions, mustard, and sauerkraut on a white background
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The New York-style hot dog is an all-beef hot dog that is topped with mustard (typically yellow or brown mustard), warm sauerkraut, and chopped white onions. German immigrants sold their version of hot dogs out of carts during the 1860s. These hot dogs are prepared by cooking the hot dogs directly in the sauerkraut and its juices. Then you place the hot dog in the bun, top it with mustard, the cooked sauerkraut, and finish it off with chopped onions.

Mexican street corn hot dogs

Hand holding Mexican street style corn cilantro and cheese on hotdog on a teal background
The popular street food known as Elote adds an extra level of flavor to your grilled hot dogs. Simply grill a few ears of corn alongside your hot dogs. Once the corn is heated through, shave the corn kernels into a bowl, add some mayonnaise, chopped cilantro, chopped serrano or jalapeno peppers, some cotija cheese, and sprinkle some chili powder in. Give it a good stir, and then add it to your grilled hot dog. Now you have two different street food items combined into one for a wonderful crunch and flavor.

Grilled cheese hot dogs

Perhaps known as one of the best meals when you aren’t feeling well, or it’s a rainy day, the grilled cheese sandwich is at the top of that list. Now imagine if you took some shredded cheddar cheese and melted it onto the grilled hot dog and bun. You have the grilled cheese sandwich meets grilled hot dog and your cheese pull game will never be the same. The ooey-gooey cheesy flavor will take you away from the rainy day blues.

Frito Pie chili dogs

Another favorite is the Frito Pie version of the hot dog. If you are unfamiliar with Frito Pie, it also goes by the name the Walking Taco. Either way, do yourself a favor and find one in your area — they’re delicious! If you can’t find any in your area, never fear, they are super-easy to create. Boil or grill your hot dog, place it in the bun, and add chili con carne, Frito chips, shredded cheddar cheese, sliced jalapenos, and chopped white onions. Be forewarned, though — these are messy, so make sure you have plenty of napkins on hand.

Carolina hot dogs

A hot dog with coleslaw, onions, and chili next to mustard dressing on a white background
Image used with permission by copyright holder

North and South Carolina have a set list of ingredients for hamburgers and hot dogs. The Carolina-style hot dog is a hot dog bun and hot dog that is topped with chili with meat, chopped onions, and coleslaw, and sometimes mustard. The chili is typically prepared with ground beef and beans. Carolina coleslaw is a vinegar-based slaw that accents the deep rich flavors of the chili. Throw it all together and you have the perfect combination of a hearty and mildly spicy chili stew and crunchy coleslaw with a light vinegar flavor.

Buffalo chicken dogs

This hot dog combines the flavors of the beloved buffalo chicken wing with the classic hot dog. Add the shredded chicken on to your dog and then the key ingredient: buffalo sauce. The spicy vinegar-based sauce with cayenne pepper gives the dish its signature kick. Then top it off with crumbled blue cheese for a creamy and tangy contrast, chopped scallions for a bit of bite, and a drizzle of ranch dressing to cool things down a bit. This hot dog is dressed up in all the delicious elements of buffalo wings.

Avocado crema hot dogs

This is another Mexican-style hot dog topping, but it’s quite a bit different from the one above. It gives your dog a cool and refreshing topping. For the avocado crema, blend avocado with some kind of cream, like sour cream. Add the cotija cheese, and finally, top it off with a squeeze of lime.

There are plenty of combinations you can work with but the star of the show is always the hot dog. Make sure you pick up some quality hot dogs brands, after all, your meals are only as good as the products you use.

Joe Morales
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Joe Morales is a trained chef with over five years of experience working in fine dining and Michelin recommended restaurants…
Need an energy boost? Try these 12 foods high in vitamin B12
Try incorporating these foods to meet your daily vitamin B12 needs
Seafood that is high in vitamin B12

Vitamin B12, also known as cobalamin, is an essential nutrient that helps with cellular energy production, brain function, DNA creation, and more. As a trainer and nutritionist, I am always encouraging my clients to pay attention to their daily vitamin B12 intake, as it can help ward off symptoms like fatigue and anemia. Getting enough of this specific nutrient can be especially concerning for those who follow vegetarian and vegan diets, as most foods high in vitamin B12 are only found in animal products.

For adults, the daily recommendation is 2.4 micrograms. To make sure you are getting in enough to support your overall health, keep reading to learn about the best foods to include in your diet.
Clams

Read more
How to break a fast: The best foods to eat
What to eat (and drink) when you're ready to chow down after a fast
Bowls of bone broth on a tray

While fasting has been done for thousands of years, it's become a more well-known practice. Whether for health benefits or to simply provide a challenge, many people are partaking in various fasting methods. As a trainer and nutritionist, I have worked with numerous clients who are fans of intermittent fasting, especially.

How to fast can be pretty straightforward, but what about how to break a fast? Being aware of the right foods and beverages to consume and when can make the process of returning to your normal eating routine that much easier on the body Is important. Keep reading to learn everything you need to know.
Bone broth

Read more
The 6 best Marsala wine cocktail recipes to make
With good Marsala wine, you can make some quality cocktails
Florio Marsala barrels

If you know Marsala wine at all, it's almost certainly as a cooking ingredient. This fortified wine comes from the island of Sicily in Italy, is similar to port or Maderia, and is best considered a kind of dessert wine. But you can make Marsala wine cocktails, too, even if they aren't commonly seen in the U.S. Bartenders abroad do embrace Marsala as a cocktail ingredient, and you can, too.

"We like to mix with Marsala. It is a wine that gives a drink elegance, mouthfeel, and sweetness -- and some spicyness," said bartender Marco Fabbiano in Lecce, Puglia (translated from German). Bartenders in Italy, especially in Sicily, where the wine originates, aren't afraid to use this ingredient in their cocktails. According to Fabbiano, plenty of locals like to drink Marsala neat, but they also enjoy working it into cocktails in their bar, the Laurus Cocktail Experience.

Read more