Skip to main content

The best psychological horror movies to stream for a serious scare

From The Shining to Saw, these psychological horror movies will get under your skin

The Shining
Warner Bros.

Horror might be the most popular genre in movies. Part of the reason it’s so reliable, though, and has so many die-hard fans is that there are so many genres within horror that speak to the different ways humans can get scared.

One of the most effective types of horror doesn’t involve possessions or zombies or supernatural threats. Instead, it simply involves the psychology of the human brain, which, when exploited, can lead us to do things that we might never imagine. These psychological horror movies are all about the ways in which we can destroy ourselves, and because they’re some of the best ever made, they might linger with you long after the credits start rolling.

Recommended Videos

Speak No Evil (2022)

Speak No Evil
97m
Genre
Horror, Thriller
Stars
Morten Burian, Sidsel Siem Koch, Fedja van Huêt
Directed by
Christian Tafdrup
Watch on Amazon
Speak No Evil does have a more American, 2024 remake that has its own merits. For this list, though, the 2022 film is a better fit. The movie tells the story of a Danish couple who become friends with a Dutch couple on vacation and are months later invited to the Dutch couple’s secluded wooded cabin. What starts as a slightly awkward comedy of manners between two families with different ways of life becomes increasingly tense as the boundaries of polite behavior are pushed to their breaking point. Speak No Evil is profoundly mean and unsettling, but the movie is best experienced if you go in totally spoiler-free.
Speak No Evil Trailer #1 (2022)

Black Swan (2010)

Black Swan
109m
Genre
Drama, Thriller, Horror
Stars
Natalie Portman, Mila Kunis, Vincent Cassel
Directed by
Darren Aronofsky
Watch on max
One of the great things about some psychological thrillers is that you can be so tethered to the experiences of a single character that it can be difficult to even tell if what you’re seeing is real. That’s very much the headspace that Black Swan puts you in from the minute the movie starts. Telling the story of an elite ballet dancer who begins to unravel just as she finds out that she’s been cast as the lead in Swan Lake, the movie features a tour de force performance from Natalie Portman, as well as some of the most disturbing imagery Darren Aronofsky has ever put on screen.

Hereditary (2018)

Hereditary
128m
Genre
Horror, Mystery, Thriller
Stars
Toni Collette, Alex Wolff, Gabriel Byrne
Directed by
Ari Aster
Watch on Amazon
Ari Aster has proven to be one of the most interesting new directors to hit Hollywood in recent years, and Hereditary is the ideal calling card. Telling the story of a family who discovers the sinister legacy that they have inherited from their matriarch, the movie is really about how years of buried trauma can come to the surface following a single traumatic event. Hereditary is an exercise in extraordinary control of tension, and it features several virtuosic sequences where the acting and direction feel designed to make you clench your fist.
Hereditary | Official Trailer HD | A24

Saw (2004)

Saw
103m
Genre
Horror, Mystery, Crime
Stars
Cary Elwes, Leigh Whannell, Danny Glover
Directed by
James Wan
Watch on Peacock
The Saw franchise has become a fascinating exercise in watching people do terrible things to themselves and one another, but the first installment is great in part because it adds a pscyhological component. The film tells the story of two men who find themselves chained to opposite ends of a filthy bathroom with no idea how they got there. As they unravel the puzzle of their own kidnapping, they begin to realize that the man pulling the strings is looking to punish them for their past misdeeds.
Saw (2004) Official Trailer #1 - James Wan Movie

The Blair Witch Project (1999)

The Blair Witch Project
81m
Genre
Horror, Mystery
Stars
Rei Hance, Joshua Leonard, Michael C. Williams
Directed by
Daniel Myrick, Eduardo Sánchez
Watch on Peacock
A movie so terrifying that many people thought it might be real, The Blair Witch Project follows three teenagers who are making a documentary about a local murderer of legend in a small town. When the trio lose their way in the woods, though, things take a sinister turn as they begin to realize that the legend they were there to document might be more real than they thought. Blair Witch is terrifying in part because of all the things that it only implies, and all these years later, it still has the same raw power it did when it first premiered.
The Blair Witch Project (1999) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers

The Wicker Man (1973)

The Wicker Man
93m
Genre
Horror
Stars
Edward Woodward, Christopher Lee, Britt Ekland
Directed by
Robin Hardy
Watch on Amazon
Telling the story of a police detective who travels to a small, secluded island because he is investigating the disappearance of a child. This conservative policeman finds himself at odds with this remote community, many of whom practice pagan rituals and flout their sexuality. Recognizing that something sinister may be at work, this policeman resolves to get to the bottom of the mystery, burrowing deeper into the island’s history in order to learn the truth. The Wicker Man is shocking and delightful and strange from minute one.
The Wicker Man (1973) Official Trailer - Christopher Lee, Diane Cilento Horror Movie HD

The Shining (1980)

The Shining
144m
Genre
Horror, Thriller
Stars
Jack Nicholson, Shelley Duvall, Danny Lloyd
Directed by
Stanley Kubrick
Watch on max
Stanley Kubrick’s horror classic likely belongs on any list in which it even remotely qualifies. Telling the story of a family who move to a resort in Colorado to serve as caretakers while it is closed for the winter, the film is chiefly about the father’s degradation into total madness. Featuring one of Jack Nicholson’s great performance, which is perfectly matched by the sinister setting of the Overlook Hotel, every sequence from The Shining is famous, and with good reason. Horror conventions have changed in the decades since it was released, but it remains one of the scariest movies ever made.
The Shining - Official Trailer [1980] HD

Misery (1990)

Misery
107m
Genre
Drama, Thriller
Stars
James Caan, Kathy Bates, Richard Farnsworth
Directed by
Rob Reiner
Watch on Amazon
Stephen King is a master of psychological horror, and Misery is one of the best adaptations of his work. The film tells the story of an author of popular fiction who gets into a terrible car crash, and finds himself being taken care of by one of his biggest fans. Her obsession with his work takes a dark turn, though, when she discovers that he’s killing off her favorite character. In the seclusion of her cabin, she forces him to begin work on a new novel that will set right what she feels he did wrong, with increasingly severe consequences for bad behavior.
Misery (1990) - Official Trailer
Movie images and data from:
Joe Allen
Contributor
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
Top picks for March: The best movies on Paramount+
Though a newer entry to the streaming world, Paramount+ has some good picks
Tom Cruise in Top Gun: Maverick

Paramount Plus is one of the newer arrivals on the streaming scene, and while its roster is rolling out plenty of exciting streaming original and acquired shows, there are plenty of movies on Paramount Plus that are worth exploring. From the classic to the current and from the vintage to the very new, Paramount+ offers an excellent movie lineup that rivals any other streaming service, even Netflix.
That might seem hard to believe, but between its library of classic titles and the fact that Paramount still puts new movies out every year, there are few services that offer you more bang for your buck. Personally, I could spend all day perusing the streaming service without running out of interesting things to watch.

Interstellar (2014)

Read more
Must-see films: The best movies on Peacock this March
Peacock is a TV service, but it also has a great catalog of movies to stream, too
Jack Black in Bernie.

A fun bit of historic TV trivia is that the original NBC peacock logo was first implemented in 1956 to highlight the network's new color programming. Even though the logo has gone through numerous iterations since then, the network has stuck with the colorful bird, in one form or another, for going on six decades now. It’s fitting, then, that Peacock is known most for its TV programming, highlighted by shows like The Office, Parks and Rec, and the self-mocking (and hilarious) 30 Rock. If you are on Peacock for the shows, however, don't overlook that the platform is also home to a number of great movies spanning cinema history, including everything from great comedy to excellent sports movies.

Below, I've picked out some of the best movies available on the service. I was surprised to see just how many greats there are to choose from, and I'm confident that whatever you like to watch, you'll find something good below.

Read more
March’s best: Shows on Max that will keep you hooked
From new originals to the best shows in HBO history, these are great shows to stream on Max
Scene from Succession

HBO Max was one of the most popular streaming services in the world due to the volume and the quality of the shows and movies on the platform. You've probably noticed when you log into HBO Max that the platform has been replaced by Max. What does this mean? WarnerMedia and Discovery have merged all of their content into one convenient location. You can still enjoy all of the shows like Succession and The Sopranos that were available on HBO Max, and this new streaming service also includes the kinds of reality shows that were available on Discovery+. Essentially, the libraries of the two services have been merged.
As is the case for many young TV lovers, HBO was one of the places I checked first for great TV, and some of the shows on this list made me realize everything that TV was capable of. What's even better, though, is that Max always has another show on deck.
Whatever kind of show you're looking for, you're likely to find it on Max. From iconic dramas to some of the funniest comedies ever created, every show on this list is a must-watch, whether it's 30 years old or just came out this year. Here are the best Max shows.

The Wire (2002)

Read more