Skip to main content

Behind the drinks: The creator of the Penicillin and Paper Plane shares his secrets

Sam Ross on modern mixology

Not many bartenders can say they invented a modern classic cocktail. Sam Ross, the brains behind some of the best bars in America—first Milk & Honey and then Attaboy—has created two.

In the early 2000s, Ross concocted both the Paper Plane and the Penicillin. The first, a sibling of The Last Word that shed new light on the blending capabilities of amaro. The second, a drink that reexamined the way we look at Scotch. These are dialed-in recipes that will likely live on for generations to come.

Recommended Videos

On creating modern classics

Barman pouring paper plane cocktail
Maksym Fesenko / Shutterstock

Ross is the first to admit these were ultimately career-changing drinks. The recipes took off and opened doors. They earned him press and were riffed-on all over the globe.

“These cocktails have been around for 17 and 19 years already so they do have a decent following out there in the cocktail consumer category,” he says. “I was hoping they were going to sell well but I think we were all pretty surprised at how quickly the first batch got blown through!”

You know your drinks have made it when not only they show up on bar menus from coast to coast, but the RTD sector comes knocking. Recently, Ross collaborated with Tip Top (one of our favorite RTD cocktail brands) to create canned versions of his two most famous creations.

“Tip Top chased me down for a long time to collaborate on these cocktails but I was being very elusive,” Ross says. “I would guess that the reason behind this was I didn’t think you could translate the brightness and freshness of a citrus cocktail into canned form and for it to be any good. When I finally tasted through some of Tip Top’s other creations, I quickly realized that these guys had figured out how to do it and do it well!”

The challenges in transitioning a drink from the bar to the can presents its challenges, from that zap of freshness to presentation. “I was only going to work with the team on these drinks if they were to allow me to be involved in every step of the process,” he says. “Obviously tasting through the many rounds of samples, but also the packaging and launch. Tip Top was 100 percent on board with this. They are absolute professionals and were so easy to work with.”

The results dropped in can form not too long ago. The Paper Plane blends bourbon, lemon, aperitivo bitters, and amaro liqueur. As for the Penicillin, it’s a relatively simple but oh-so-satisfying mix of Scotch, lemon, ginger, and honey. Ross worked with James Beard Award-nominated mixologist Miles Macquarrie  to create these takes.

The state of mixology

penicillin
Getty Images/iStockphoto Copyright: brent Hofacker

The experience at Attaboy is at once bespoke and timeless. All the details add up and while RTD drinks clearly keep improving, the best of bar experiences is still a special thing.

“We place a firm emphasis on classic cocktails and modern variations using the highest quality ingredients,” Ross says of Attaboy. “We are a menu-less bar which allows our bartenders to talk you through your options and allows for a unique and tailored experience. It also allows you to get back to conversing with your company instead of trying to decipher a long and complicated menu in a dark bar!”

What’s next? Ross suggests we’re seeing a lot of creativity around the globe right now and that it’s an exciting time indeed to be a cocktail drinker. “It seems bars are dividing up between reimagining classics and more modern lab/kitchen type technique driven cocktails.” he says. “And let me tell you, both are great.”

But we cannot overlook the hospitality angle. “I think the ultimate goal at all the spots should be, ‘are you having a good time?’ We should always be having a good time when we are out spending our hard-earned money on fancy drinks,” he says.

Additional tips

Bartender adding orange zest juice to a Gin Fizz cocktail in the glass on the bar counter
Maksym Fesenko / Shutterstock

The bar wizard was nice enough to offer a brief bulleted list of lessons he’s learned over the years:

  • Stop putting big ice in delicate coupes.
  • Smoked cocktails are never good.
  • Drink your drink how you want to drink it. You’re the one paying for it.
  • Drink the good stuff, life is too short for bad cocktails.

Cheers to that, good sir. And what’s he drinking? A few good things. “As the weather turns colder, I just adore American whiskey,” he says. “It’s also Martini season all the way up until Christmas, so take advantage. Oh, and Spritzes: Spritz-ify anything on your back bar, I dare you.”

And you can always do some armchair travel to some more a bit closer to the equator “Lastly, if you can get your hands on a Tip Top Mai Tai, you can live out those summer beach vibes all winter long.”

Don’t stop there, check out our recent features on everything from the best Italian cocktails to the best Campari cocktails. Cin cin!

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Master the vodka martini: Tips for a heavenly cocktail
We know James Bond likes his vodka martini shaken, not stirred, how do you like yours?
Vodka martinis with olives

The martini is a beloved cocktail, but it's hard to order one like you know what you're doing. That's because it is a drink that can come in so many forms, and everyone has their own preference for what they like best. There is more than one way to make a martini, and crafting a martini the "proper" way is a subject of debate. Does a martini have to employ gin or vodka? Will the Martini Police pop up out of nowhere if you use vodka instead of gin?

The truth is, neither is wrong. Shocking, right? We know you have a lot of questions, so we spoke with former master mixologist of Beam Suntory, Bobby Gleason, to find out the origins of the vodka martini — a popular twist to the gin martini. And later on, we’re going to learn how to make the best vodka martini in the whole galaxy. Trust us, it's one of the easiest cocktails to master and is perfect for those who want to enjoy a refreshing vodka-based martini without the botanical flavors of gin.
Classic vodka martini recipe

Read more
The Gibson cocktail: A pickle lover’s dream come true
This classic take on the martini features a pickled twist
Gibson cocktail

Of the many types of martinis that exist, the one that everyone recognizes is the dirty martini that uses olive brine to add a salty note to the drink. But there's another martini version that you might want to explore if you love savory flavors, called the Gibson. The Gibson cocktail is one that's not seen so often, so it's worth trying out if you want to order a martini like a pro.

If you’re a martini fan and you’ve never branched out to any of the other versions of the popular drink, you’re missing out. Maybe you don’t want to go as far as whipping up an appletini or an espresso martini, but you can make this simple take on the drink. All you need to do is make your favorite martini and add a pickled cocktail onion (or two). That’s it.
Gibson cocktail recipe

Read more
Fresh and fruity mezcal drinks for Día de los Muertos
Get mixing with tangerine juice, blood orange, and Sal De Gusano
fruity mezcal dia de los muertos cocktails la calaverita 6

As Día de los Muertos is celebrated across Mexico, the US, and beyond this weekend, now is a great time to try some tastes of Mexico in your cocktails. While your mind might go straight to tequila when you think of Mexican spirits, in recent years there has been an explosion of small batch, artisanal mezcal brands breaking into the US which means that high-quality mezcal is more widely available than ever.

The brand Mezcal Union has two cocktails to celebrate the holiday, making use of fruity ingredients to add a touch of sweetness and interest to the smoky flavors of mezcal. There's the La Calaverita which uses tangerine or mandarin juice, plus some pumpkin spice syrup to bring in a touch of fall flavor, and adds a smoked salt rim to enhance the smoky and savory flavors of the mezcal.

Read more