Skip to main content

Everyone is dunking on MLB’s Oakland Athletics about a gift they gave player Miguel Cabrera – here’s why

Miguel Cabrera's gift from the Oakland A's was both cheap and stunningly insensitive

Miguel Cabrera holding the wine alongside the manager of the Oakland A's.
@athletics / Instagram

Few players in the history of Major League Baseball (MLB) have had more storied and impressive careers than Miguel Cabrera. Cabrera is in an elite club, and now that he’s coming to the end of what will be the final season of his career, teams are offering him gifts on his last tour through their ballparks.

These gifts are typically nice tokens of how much Cabrera has meant to the league over his time playing the sport, but more than a few eyebrows were raised when it came time for the Oakland Athletics to present their gift to the Tigers legend. The A’s decided to gift Cabrera with a bottle of wine, and when eagle-eyed fans looked the bottle up, they realized that it only cost $90.

Recommended Videos

The A’s are a famously budget-conscious team, and while taxes may have brought the total up to $100, it’s not like they were really willing to spend big money when it came time to honor one of baseball’s greats. The frugality of the gift was one major problem, but as it turns out, it was far from the only issue with this particular gift.

Cabrera is a recovering alcoholic

It would be one thing if the gift was just cheap, but as it turns out, it was also incredibly tone-deaf. Cabrera has been open about his struggles with alcoholism in the past, and in 2010, he spent three months in outpatient treatment for alcoholism. So this gift wasn’t just a cheap way to send off a great, it was also something that Cabrera has worked hard for more than a decade to stay away from.

Naturally, people discovered that the A’s had given him a cheap gift and that the gift was a particularly bad fit for Cabrera, and they were merciless, and justifiably so.

“That’s probably the yearly salary they’ll offer Ohtani this off-season,” one person wrote under an Instagram post about the story. The A’s are famously unwilling to pay for major talent, and it has ensured that they are unable to compete with the best teams in the league.

“But it was signed by the whole A’s teams so that’s gotta bump the value of the bottle to $68.72,” another person added.

“A’s Front Office: We still got wine from the 2020 playoffs, right? Give him one of those. Not one of the nice ones though,” a third person joked.

Clearly, baseball fans don’t think much of the A’s in general and weren’t necessarily all that shocked that they decided to give Cabrera such a cheap and thoughtless gift. As some were quick to point out, though, it’s not like Cabrera is hurting for money or looking for lavish gifts. He’s earned more than enough to sustain him over the course of his career, and all the gifts he’s getting as part of this farewell tour are really just icing on the cake.

Joe Allen
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
Topics
Beginner’s guide to cigar shapes and sizes — and why they matter
Why your cigar choice says more about you than your watch (and how to pick the perfect one)
A collection of cigars

Walking into a cigar shop and facing what seems like a million options is enough to make anyone panic. Cigars stacked everywhere, each with a strange name, size, and a slightly different shape from the last one. If you haven't done this before, it's tempting to just grab something, anything, and run!But hold on a second. Those shapes actually matter. They aren't just there to look fancy or make things confusing. The size and shape change the whole experience of smoking that cigar – how it tastes, burns, and feels. It's kind of like how driving a tiny sports car is way different than driving a big truck. Both get you where you're going, but the experience along the way is not the same.

What are cigar vitolas?

Read more
The writer of one of Netflix’s biggest drama is taking on James Bond next
We still don't know who will star in this new installment.
James Bond at a casino

The news that Denis Villeneuve would be taking on the next James Bond film was certainly exciting for many, and as we continue to speculate about who might take over as 007, we're also learning more about who else will be working behind the scenes on the film.

We now know that Steven Knight, the writer behind Peaky Blinders, will be writing the next Bond movie. While Knight is best known for his work on TV, which includes Peaky Blinders and the recent Stephen Graham series A Thousand Blows, he's also the writer behind Spencer and Maria.

Read more
Every new Game of Thrones spinoff explained
George R.R. Martin's television world continues to grow
Matt Smith starring in House of the Dragon

When it first aired on HBO in the early 2010s, Game of Thrones dazzled audiences with revolutionary special effects and terrific acting in a unique fantasy world. Based on author George R.R. Martin's series of novels, the universe depicts the battles between several different noble families as they try to climb to the top of the continent of Westeros, both politically and figuratively. The war scenes, family drama, and massive number of characters helped make the story feel fresh and new every time a new episode aired.

As Martin's attention shifted to television and away from his books, fans have looked to the TV series to finish some of the stories he couldn't finish on the page. Game of Thrones left fans wanting more, despite its poorly received finale, and a plethora of spinoffs are on the way. House of the Dragon already has two seasons completed, and there are several others in the coming years to look forward to.
House of the Dragon
House of the Dragon finished its second season in 2024. The show chronicles the heated family dynamics of the Targaryen empire almost two centuries before the events of Game of Thrones. The third season should pick up the civil war between Queen Rhaenyra's forces and King Aegon's after a slow-building conflict throughout the second act.

Read more