Skip to main content

Presumed Innocent season 2: Everything we know so far

Here's what we know about the Apple TV+ hit's second season

Jake Gyllenhaal in Presumed Innocent.
Apple TV+

While it may not have seemed like a juggernaut when it first premiered, Apple TV+’s Presumed Innocent has turned into one of the streamer’s biggest hits of the year. Apple has announced that the series is their most-watched drama of all time, which may explain why a second season is already in the works.

The series is adapted from a novel of the same name by Scott Turow which was first turned into a movie, and tells the story of a prosecutor who finds himself accused of murder, and has to work to keep his life and family together in light of the allegations. Now that the first season has wrapped up its run, many want to know what season 2 will hold and when it might premiere. Here’s what we know:

Recommended Videos

What is the release date for Presumed Innocent season 2?

Presumed Innocent Limited Series Trailer | Jake Gyllenhaal, Ruth Negga, Bill Camp, David E. Kelley

No release date has been announced for the second season yet, but given that the first season just concluded its run in July of 2024, it’s safe to say we won’t see a second season until sometime in 2025 at the earliest.

Given the protracted timelines for many series these days, it’s possible that the wait could be even longer. After all, a new season has to be written and cast, and then they have to go through production and editing. Severance, another hugely popular Apple show, originally premiered in 2022 and won’t be back on the air until 2025. Here’s hoping the Presumed Innocent cap is not that long.

What is the plot of Presumed Innocent season 2?

Jake Gyllenhaal in Presumed Innocent
Apple TV+

The show’s second season is presumably still being written, and it’s unclear how it may be connected to the first season. In the finale for season 1, we learn who actually killed Carolyn, and the reveal is not at all what you might have expected. Rusty is found not guilty at his trial and comes home to accuse his wife, Barbara, of committing the murder. She adamantly denies that she had anything to do with it, but Rusty says that he knows it was her because he put a tracker on her car.

That’s when their daughter, Jaden, enters the room and confesses to the murder. The family is devastated and left to pick up the pieces in the case’s aftermath.

Season 2 is set to follow an entirely different case, but it’s unclear whether any of the show’s existing cast will return in some capacity. Jake Gyllenhaal is unlikely to lead the show’s second season, but he could appear briefly to connect the two cases.

In building toward a second season, the writers could choose to adapt one of Turow’s follow-up novels. He released The Burden of Proof a few years after Presumed Innocent. That novel follows Sandy Stern in the aftermath of the events of the first book. The novel follows Sandy as he learns more about his wife after her death. The only issue with this route is that Sandy isn’t actually a character in the show. Instead, Rusty’s defense attorney is named Mya, so it’s possible that season 2 could follow her as she moves to a new case.

The other option for a second season could come from Turow’s 2011 sequel novel Innocent, which follows Rusty and Peter Sarsgaard’s Tommy Molto 20 years later as the story turns to the mysterious death of Rusty’s wife. If they went that direction, they would likely recast both central roles.

It’s also possible that the show diverges from Turow completely, and creates an entirely original story that has many of the same preoccupations as the first season had.

Is there a trailer for season 2 of Presumed Innocent?

There is no trailer for the second season yet, and plenty of creative decisions still have to be made about season 2 before we will get one. We don’t even know who will be in the cast or what the story will be focused on.

Who is in the cast of Presumed Innocent season 2?

The cast for the new season has not yet been announced, but it feels safe to say that it will be largely new. Gyllenhaal is unlikely to return to his central role, at least as the main character, and many of the supporting players will likely be different as well. There may be some connective tissue from the first season, but most of the characters in a second season will be played by entirely new actors.

What we do know, though, is that a lot of the behind the scenes talent will be back for the second season. J.J. Abrams, Rachel Rusch Rich, Dustin Thomason, and Matthew Tinker will be back as executive producers, and creator David E. Kelley and author Scott Turow will also serve in that role.

Joe Allen
Contributor
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
Everything we know so far about Only Murders in the Building season 5
Yet another homicide has happened at the Arconia in Only Murders in the Building
Steve Martin, Martin Short and Selena Gomez in Only Murders in the Building

Only Murders in the Building season 4 came to a close with one of its most succinct finales in the series. Charles, Oliver, and Mabel solved the murder of Sazz Pataki and brought justice to Jane Lynch's character in an orderly fashion, but there would be no further seasons of this spooky show if the murderous pattern in the Arconia were to end this time. The episode closed with two more mysteries to be solved next season.
Only Murders in the Building has been one of the biggest hits on Hulu since it premiered in 2021. Steve Martin, Selena Gomez, and Martin Short make up one of the most endearing trios ever assembled on TV. Martin and Short have been longtime friends and collaborators, therefore Gomez's addition is what elevated the show into a more dynamic and age-diverse comedy. We're so glad they'll all be back for a fifth go-around. This is everything we know about Only Murders in the Building season 5. 

What will Only Murders in the Building season 5 be about?
It looks like there will be two different murder cases in the fifth season of the show. The main murder storyline revolves around Lester the doorman. At the end of the fourth season finale, the podcasting trio finds Lester's corpse in the fountain outside of the Arconia. Blood has pooled around the outside of the fountain in one of the show's more graphic depictions of violence in four seasons so far. This comes on the heels of a joyous union between Oliver and Loretta. The juxtaposition between happiness and sadness works so well in Only Murders in the Building and allows it to operate as a drama and a dark comedy at the same time.

Read more
9 best baseball documentaries to watch now that the season is over
These docs on the diamond will teach and entertain!
Arial view of full baseball stadium

There's just something so rich and satisfying about baseball. Whether you're a fan of the diamond or not, the sport is undeniably ingrained in American culture in a way other games like football, basketball, and hockey can't quite match. One of the reasons for this is the expansive historical context against which the sport can be measured. Major League Baseball has been going on since the middle of the 19th century. Kids and parents have been playing catch in the yard for just as long.

Documentary films have done a fantastic job of capturing the magic and the significance of America's pastime. They can be hours upon hours of interviewing and found footage, or they can share just a fleeting moment of the game, a single story about a player or team that matters all these years later. These are the best baseball documentaries for diehard fans of the sport and newcomers alike!

Read more
‘Presumed Innocent’ is adapting a totally new novel for its second season
The series is set to adapt a novel that will be released in 2026.
Jake Gyllenhaal in Presumed Innocent.

When it first debuted on Apple TV+, Presumed Innocent almost immediately became one of the streaming service's biggest hits. So big, in fact, that even though the show was intended to be a limited series, it was renewed for a second season.

Given that the first season was adapted from a novel and movie of the same name, there were naturally questions about what the second season might focus on it. The Scott Turow novel that was the basis for the first season is being jettisoned for the second, according to reporting in Deadline. This new season will have a female lead, and will adapt Dissection of a Murder, an upcoming novel from Jo Murray.

Read more