Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Netflix, Disney+, or Max? All the major streaming services, ranked

Find out which subscription to keep, cancel, or purchase

Remote close-up watching TV
Tomas Urbelionis / Shutterstock

In the old days of streaming, things were fairly simple. You subscribed to Netflix, or maybe if you were very cool or rich, Netflix and Hulu, and you watched what was available. Now, the streaming landscape has gotten a lot more crowded, and that means it can be hard to decide where you should invest your well-earned cash.

Netflix may have plenty of great TV shows, but is Hulu’s library better? What about Peacock or Max? To help you sort through the streaming morass, we’ve ranked the major streaming services from worst to best and included some basic information on their prices.

Recommended Videos

9. Peacock

The Peacock TV logo on a black background.
NBC

Subscriptions:

  • Premium: $7.99/month
  • Premium Plus: $13.99/month

Peacock has a couple of solid original shows, including Girls5Eva and Poker Face, but none have broken through to the extent that the service has managed to catch on. On top of that, its list of available movie titles is relatively anemic, and while there are some great old NBC shows on Peacock, the service is really for people who want to watch The Office repeatedly. The cheapest subscription option is relatively affordable, but it does limit what’s available to you on the service and comes with ads. Premium Plus gets you an ad-free experience, as well as your local NBC affiliate.

8. Paramount+

The Paramount Plus logo on a bright blue background.
Paramount+

Subscriptions:

  • Paramount+ Essential: $7.99/month or $59.99/year
  • Paramount+ with Showtime: $12.99/month or $119.99/year

Perhaps Paramount+’s greatest folly is that Paramount’s hallmark show, Yellowstone, isn’t on the service. Paramount+ has some Yellowstone spin-offs and plenty of other performances from Taylor Sheridan that are worth checking out. In addition, it has a solid library of old Paramount films, and if you splurge and add Showtime, there’s an even more extensive library of movies and shows. The service’s two biggest draws might be Yellowjackets and the Star Trek universe, particularly Strange New Worlds, which has broken through in a significant way. The Showtime add-on will also get you your local CBS affiliate station.

7. Tubi

The Tubi logo

Tubi is for all the people out there who want something to watch but aren’t too terribly fussy about what it is. It’s an entirely free but ad-supported streaming service, meaning its show and movie lineup is pretty random. Having said that, there are plenty of worthy titles available there as long as you’re willing to do a little bit of digging. Tubi is as close as the streaming era gets to replicating the feeling of just finding something on cable TV, and for plenty of people, that’s exactly the experience they’re looking for.

6. Apple TV+

The Apple TV Plus Logo
Apple

Subscriptions: 

  • $9.99/month

It’s amazing that Apple TV+ is not dead last on this list, given that it has a very limited archival library (which it’s working to build up) and only releases a new thing roughly once a week. Even so, Apple has invested in many of the right things to ensure that its streaming service is always discussed, even if it doesn’t have a vast library. Between winning Best Picture with CODA and critically acclaimed or widely watched shows Ted Lasso and The Morning Show, Apple has created enough buzz around its content to make people think they should subscribe, even if it’s not the kind of service you can browse forever.

5. Amazon Prime Video

Amazon Prime Video logo on blue
Amazon Prime

Subscriptions: 

  • $14.99/month or $139.99/year for full membership
  • $8.99/month for just Prime Video

Amazon has put some real effort into building out the kind of original library that can compete with services like Netflix, but those efforts have been, at best, a mixed bag. Still, Prime Video has had some major hits, including The Boys and Fleabag, and it’s not like Amazon is in danger of going out of business. The best thing about Prime Video, though, is that it’s free with an Amazon subscription, which means that millions of people have access to the streaming service as a perk that comes with their 2-day shipping.

4. Hulu

Hulu logo
Hulu

Subscriptions: 

  • Hulu (with ads): $7.99/month or $79.99/year
  • Hulu (no ads): $17.99/month
  • Disney+ (with ads) and Hulu (with ads): $9.99/month
  • Disney+ (no ads) and Hulu (no ads): $19.99/month
  • Disney+ (with ads), Hulu (with ads), and ESPN+ (with ads): $14.99/month
  • Disney+ (no ads), Hulu (no ads), and ESPN+ (with ads): $24.99/month
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ with ads: $16.99/month
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ with no ads: $29.99/month

The old standby, Hulu has persevered since the earliest days of streaming and still has a rock-solid library of new and vintage TV shows that are well worth your time. On top of that, the Disney bundle means that Hulu can be a nice add-on for parents who feel obligated to have a Disney+ subscription, and there’s also a bundle that includes Max. Hulu is worth subscribing to in its own right, in part because it’s a great resource for anyone who wants to brush up on classic television. If you’re not a TV nerd, though, Hulu’s partnership with FX means that some of the best shows on TV still wind up on the streamer eventually.

3. Disney+

Disney+ cover on a blue background
Disney+

Subscriptions: 

  • Disney+ (with ads): $7.99/month
  • Disney+ (no ads): $13.99/month
  • Disney+ (with ads) and Hulu (with ads): $9.99/month
  • Disney+ (no ads) and Hulu (no ads): $19.99/month
  • Disney+ (with ads), Hulu (with ads), and ESPN+ (with ads): $14.99/month
  • Disney+ (no ads), Hulu (no ads), and ESPN+ (with ads): $24.99/month
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ with ads: $16.99/month
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ with no ads: $29.99/month

Disney+ came out of the gate with force, and it’s the closest to catching Netflix in terms of the sheer volume of subscribers. In spite of that success, though, Disney’s decision to ratchet up prices for the service and the issues it’s been having with quality control on its original content (see almost every Marvel show) keep it from being even higher on this list. Still, it’s hard to deny that the service has plenty of archival titles, including basically a full lineup of Disney classics that is sure to enchant every kid. And, on top of that, Disney+ has got Bluey.

2. Netflix

The official logo for Netflix.
Netflix

Subscriptions: 

  • Standard (with ads): $6.99/month
  • Standard: $15.49/month
  • Premium: $22.99/month

Netflix remains, at least in many people’s minds, the streamer to beat, but its recent track record has been a little spottier than its unimpeachable run of early success. All indications are that plenty of people still watch Netflix and consider it the best streaming service for finding what they want. Its lineup of reality TV has every other streamer beat, and they’ve successfully launched several originals that have gone on to become genuine phenomenons. Still, because it has virtually no back catalog of great TV or movies, the options are a little more limited than you might like.

1. Max

Max logo
Max

Subscriptions: 

  • With Ads: $9.99/month or $99.99/year
  • Ad-Free: $16.99/month or $169.99/year
  • Ultimate Ad-Free: $10.99/month or $209.99/year
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ (with ads): $16.99/month
  • Hulu, Max, and Disney+ (no ads): $29.99/month

Although it’s got a pretty busted user interface, Max still has the best combination of original content and library titles, even if it comes at a pretty penny. The service, which combines the catalogs of Warner Bros., HBO, and Discovery and also has a bunch of other partnerships on top of those, has such a wide array of offerings that it’s probably the best service to start with if you’re only going to bother with one. Where else can you watch classic French cinema and Shark Week without leaving a single app?

Joe Allen
Contributor
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
The best Keanu Reeves movies: A ranking of 16 classics
Keanu Reeves has had a wild journey through Hollywood, but these are the films that define his career
A still of Keanu Reeves in "John Wick"

Few actors have had the staying power of Keanu Reeves. After emerging as a fledgling star in the late 1980s, Reeves had a run of almost unparalleled success throughout the '90s and into the 2000s, starring in everything from dramas to action movies. Although it seemed for a time like his career was petering out, he's since proven that he is one of our most enduring leading men, in part because of his even-keeled, zen approach to both his work and his life.

As a famous meme often reminds us, Reeves loves movies, and we love him. Below, we've ranked the 16 best Keanu Reeves movies over the course of his career.

Read more
The ultimate Jake Gyllenhaal movie ranking: 13 films you can’t miss
Gyllenhaal is a Hollywood staple with a storied career
Jake Gyllenhaal and Robert Downey Jr. in Zodiac.

He may still be hunting for his first Oscar, but Jake Gyllenhaal has already more than proven that he's one of modern Hollywood's greatest leading men. What's made his career so fascinating is that he's mostly shied away from the biggest projects that were offered to him, barring the occasional video game adaptation.

Movies with Jake Gyllenhaal show his best performances, which speak to the wide array of roles he's willing to take on and how different his approach seems to be from project to project. He's not the kind of actor who repeats himself, and that makes every one of his performances a revelation. These are the best Jake Gyllenhaal movies over the span of his long and winding career.

Read more
The 8 best hockey movies to stream

Hockey isn't like basketball, baseball, and football in that it attracts millions of athletes in all parts of the world. Due to the need for cold weather to play outside on the ice and the need for lots of equipment, ice hockey is usually most popular in regions where these stars align, such as in the American Northwest and throughout Canada and Russia.

You don't need to like playing the sport yourself though to pop in a hockey flick and enjoy the spiritual and emotional triumphs that accompany hockey's culture. The best hockey movies bring up questions of patriotism, family, racism, political allegiances, and so much more. Hockey's history is filled with anger, fighting, and even tears of joy. These films will make you think about teamwork and camaraderie in a new light, whether you stream them on Netflix or buy a DVD on Amazon.

Read more