Skip to main content

Thrift shopping: How to do it like a pro

Tips to help you make the most of secondhand style thrifting

Person thrift shopping
Image used with permission by copyright holder

So, you want to learn how to thrift shop like a pro. And who could blame you? When done well, thrift shopping, or thrifting, can be a fantastic way to find unique, one-of-a-kind clothing that’s as stylish as it is affordable. However, it can also be time-consuming and frustratingly fruitless, leaving folks empty-handed or, worse, saddled with new duds that are little more than, well … duds.

But worry not, you burgeoning vintage aficionado, you! There are plenty of tricks you can employ to save yourself from the pitfalls of thrifting, and I’ve assembled the best of ‘em right here. Below, I’m going to walk you through every step of a successful second-hand expedition, from getting in the right mindset to navigating vintage stores like a champ.

Neon vintage sign
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The best tips for thrifting

Keep these tips in mind when you head out to the thrift shops, and you’ll have a successful trip. So, think you’re ready to thrift like a pro? Then let’s dive into these tips.

Recommended Videos

Set your expectations

First things first — you need to set realistic expectations. The fabulous thing about thrifting is you never know what you’re going to find, which means sometimes you may not find anything at all. So, it’s always better to go in with a vague plan than a specific one. That way, you won’t be too disappointed by your search. For example, it’s much easier to llook for blue blazers than to fixate on finding a slim-cut bright navy suit jacket with pronounced shoulder pads and a silk lapel. In truth, the best way to thrift is to go in with no agenda at all, and let the clothing find you.

Plan a route

Next, plan your route. Whenever I thrift, I like to go to an area in which there are a few different vintage stores, that way, I can meander through them all. Why is this important? Because it’s hard to know whether a shop’s going to be “hot” on any given day. When I say hot, I mean that a spot in which you found a plethora of fun items last month may not have a single thing you want this time around. And it makes sense — items in a thrift store come from a variety of sources (donations, acquisitions, estate sales, etc.), so the stock is always changing. Play the field and save yourself from getting stuck in a clothing desert.

Go slow

The number one mistake new thrifters make is that they don’t take their time sorting through items. It’s crucial to go slow, parsing through clothing racks with patience and precision. Vintage stores can be a bit like the Wild West, with customers rearranging items to their hearts’ content, so you’ve gotta carefully comb through each section to make sure you’re not missing anything amazing. Truly, you never know what gem might be hiding in plain sight, so give yourself the freedom to explore.

Forget gender

Another misconception is that you have to stick to gendered sections. While you may not find structured blazers or suit pants in the women’s department, you are likely to stumble upon a ton of playful tops, shirts, and jackets, which can come in handy if you’re looking for a costume or period piece. Sure, it can be a little weird to sift through blouses next to female customers, but you’ll quickly shake off the awkward vibes when you land on the piece you didn’t even realize you were looking for.

Inspect closely

Once you’ve gathered up some gems you’d like to take home, it’s time for a close inspection. Understandably, you’re buying these duds second (or, you know, fifth) hand, so it’s crucial to make sure their structural integrity is intact. Look for stains at the armpits, loose threads along the seams, and any fragile closures. Some of these things you can fix (hems, buttons), but some you just can’t (stains, smells), so you’ll need to be realistic about what you can handle. Remember: Just because something’s relatively inexpensive doesn’t mean you need to buy it.

Modify

That being said, the affordability of thrifting does mean you have some options! If you’re not totally crazy about the fit of a jacket you just bought, but are obsessed with the color and style, use some of the money you saved to get it tailored to the nines. And this goes for any number of modifications, from hemming pants to darning knit sweaters. If the bones of a garment are good, you can always make them work for your personal style, so keep an open mind.

A man using an HP laptop in his home.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Thrift shopping online vs. in stores

Let’s face it. We love the idea of saving time for other things and doing our shopping online, especially since way back in 2020, we had no choice. However, both online and in-store thrift shopping have their advantages and disadvantages. Choosing the best option for you depends on your priorities and preferences. Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of each:

Online thrifting pros:

  • Convenience: Shop from the comfort of your couch and anytime or anywhere.
  • Wider selection: Access a much larger inventory of items from various thrift stores and platforms.
  • Filtering options: Easily find what you’re looking for by brand, size, category, and sometimes even color or style.
  • Reviews and ratings: Get insights into item condition and quality from other buyers.
  • Potentially lower prices: Some online platforms offer lower prices than physical stores.

Online thrifting cons:

  • Can’t assess quality in person: Photos might not accurately show condition, material, or fit.
  • Shipping costs: Can add up, especially for larger items.
  • There’s no in-person treasure hunt thrill: You miss the fun of browsing and discovering hidden gems.
  • Returns and exchanges may be more complicated: Policies vary depending on the platform.

In-store thrifting pros:

  • Immediate quality assessment: See and feel the item before you buy it.
  • Treasure hunt thrill: Enjoy the fun of rummaging through racks and finding unexpected treasures.
  • Social experience: Connect with other shoppers and the store staff.
  • No shipping costs: Pay what you see.
  • Easier returns and exchanges: Usually, you just bring the item back to the store with your receipt.

In-store thrifting cons:

  • Limited selection: Depends on what’s available at the specific store you visit.
  • No filtering options: Finding what you’re looking for can be a time-consuming journey.
  • Less convenient: Requires travel and time commitment.
  • The conditions may vary: You might find hidden flaws or stains not readily apparent.
  • It can be crowded and overwhelming: Especially at popular stores.

Whether you’re a newbie or getting back into the vintage swing of things, you’re now equipped with all the knowledge you need to have a successful thrifting adventure.

Cody Gohl
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Cody Gohl is a Brooklyn-based writer who enjoys covering a wide range of topics, including travel, fashion, literature, LGBT…
Travel like a secret agent with 5.11’s industry defining Founder’s Jacket
Always Be Ready even when dressed for the boardroom
5.11 Founders Jacket

We have all seen James Bond travel the world and carry out missions of the utmost importance while looking stylish as Hell. The one thing that should baffle anyone in the clothing or travel industry is how he did it with not a wrinkle in sight. Of course, there are all kinds of tricks for you to get to your destination and take care of wrinkles. But then there is another problem: how do you look amazing while having everything you need? The experts in the mindset of Always Be Ready remedied both problems with the drop of the 5.11 Founder's Jacket. While it will be your best friend in everyday carry preparedness, it doesn't sacrifice the style you need either.

The jacket has been a pet project of co-founder, former CEO, and current Executive Chairman Francisco J. Morales, for years. “As someone who has been deeply involved in the design and innovation process throughout my years at 5.11, the release of the 5.11 Founder’s Jacket is incredibly special. It represents the culmination of our dedication to crafting quality gear but also tells the story of our brand's journey. I'm excited to share it with our community of professionals and enthusiasts who inspire everything we do as a brand.”
Perfect for the man on the go

Read more
How to style men’s boots with jeans: Top picks for every look
How to pair your favorite footwear with jeans
man wearing skinny jens and boots

No matter the season, there’s no denying that boots are some of the best ways to complete a denim outfit. Sturdy and quality boots can take you to any event and pair well with almost any closet. However, picking out the best men's boots for your jeans can be a struggle, especially when dealing with the numerous styles available. While these are easy-to-style options, finding the right boot can make or break your look. While the types of jeans you choose are an important factor in making the decision, ultimately it’s best to know which types of boots go with various jeans. Whether skinny or straight jeans, the following boots are the best for completing your look and make for a safe bet in any wardrobe.
Cowboy boots

With the numerous Western-inspired trends that have infiltrated the trends, it’s no secret that cowboy boots have become a regular footwear option. While cowboy boots are often seen as too niche or specific to a region, they’re a great choice for those looking to add ornate and rugged details to their look. Going back to the basics of styling, cowboy boots have always been the best partner to wear with denim. While this classic pairing has seen variations throughout the seasons, there’s no doubt that cowboy boots pair well with any jeans. Whether it’s a pair of straight jeans paired with a taller cowboy boot or a pair of slim-fitting denim with short cowboy boots, this pairing is the ultimate classic. 
Chukka Boots

Read more
Why the neckerchief is your 2025 style secret weapon
Stand out in a new and different way in 2025
Robert Talbot neckerchief

If you have read much of my writing here on The Manual, you will likely recognize some of my favorite themes and the phrases I use to communicate them. Emulate, don't imitate, so you can style yourself like some of your favorite style icons without being discouraged when you dress just like them and it doesn't work. Classics, not trends, because they never go out of style. And the one that is the most important for this particular claim I am about to make: Fashion is what you wear, style is how you wear it.

I firmly believe that being stylish isn't about restricting what you wear because others don't like it; it is about incorporating what you love into your looks in a stylish way. This is how I ended up looking at ascots and cravats and how I developed reasons why you should wear a neckerchief in 2025.

Read more