Skip to main content

Should you be wearing a sweater over your dress shirt?

A fool proof way to nail the classic look

mens sweater over dress shirt man touching his collar
Vitória Santos / Pexels

There are some styles that disappear and then come back with a vengeance. See the mom jean over the past decade with women everywhere. Then there are styles that just stay in our lexicon and never fade. Whether it is something simple like the undying coolness of a tee and jeans or the never fading stylish trend of layering, sometimes we just love something so much that we refuse to let it die. One that we have loved forever is the men’s sweater over a dress shirt. Why do we buy into this idea? What is it about this layering technique that has us smitten every cold weather season?

The answer may not be straightforward, but we think it is because it adds depth to casual outfits like a button-up and pants and dressier outfits like a sport coat and jeans. In any case, there is a way to do this so you always look fantastic, and then there are those other ways. Follow the below tips and you will never look like the step-dad from The Santa Clause. Be honest, you went and looked up whether or not Dr. Neil Miller was actually wearing one, didn’t you.

Recommended Videos

With a V-neck

Man in v-neck sweater and dress shirt
Sandro Tavares / Pexels

The V-neck sweater is the go-to for the style with a dress shirt underneath. This works the best for a few reasons. The first, and most obvious is that the dipping collar allows more room to show off the shirt underneath. The second reason, and maybe the most useful, is that the shape of the collar is the same as a vest. The V-shape allows you to wear a tie along with the collar to keep it in place and still look great under a suit coat. Here are some tips for wearing this sweater with a dress shirt:

  • Wearing a stiff collar dress shirt will keep a polished look and will showcase the knot of the tie.
  • The fit is extremely important as you don’t want it to be so tight you can see the button placard or the tie outline underneath it.
  • For a casual look, roll the sleeves of the dress shirt once over the cuff of the sweater and lose the tie.
  • Stick to structured tie knots that are middle-sized. Small knots make the shirt look too big for you and big knots take up the entire opening.

With a crew neck

Man in sweater with dress shirt under it
cottonbro studio / Pexels

This is very similar to the same look above, only we lose the extra space in the opening and it is a tight crew collar. This look is often times more casual and doesn’t look as good with a smart casual look. That means there are some foolproof ways to make this style look perfect in your casual to semi-dressed up events.

  • Stick to the button-down collar dress shirts or sport shirts anytime you can. If your collar is outside your sweater collar here it can look like a rugby polo more than a thought out look. A button-down collar keeps the tabs in check.
  • This is the best look for jeans and a sport coat. But the sport coat should be more casual. Think tweed or cashmere. If you can get one with elbow patches, that is the dream here.
  • Chunky sweaters are the way to go here, so ditch the thin merino wool and go for the fisherman’s sweaters to make this look a callback to Dawson and his pals.

The prep

Man with sweater tied over his shoulders
Анна Хазова / Pexels

Ok, we know what you are thinking, this is the definition of frat boy. But go with us here. Old money style is raging back into the forefront of the fashion world. Vintage looks are slipping back little by little and before long we will all be dressed in zoot suits or Oxford campus dress. This look is a great way to stand out without having to wear the sweater if the weather becomes unseasonably warm. Now, here are the things to keep in mind:

  • Ditch the shorts and boat shoes. Here is the truth, if you are wearing shorts and boat shoes, the weather is likely not going to be cool enough to need the sweater so it is simply for show. That is when it looks like you are right off the Harvard rowing team, and not in the good way. We would make fun of it, but their daddy would sue us.
  • Keep the sweater a solid. A pattern on this sweater will stand out and distract from the rest of the look, and it is basically an add on at this point. Keep it as a white, light blue, gray, or black depending on the look of the ensemble.
  • Don’t tie it too tight. We all remember using mom’s towels to make a cape by tying it around our necks. This shouldn’t look like that. Simply tie it one time (like the first step to tying your shoes) and leave it loose. Let gravity do the work.

With a cardigan

Man with a cardigan over dress shirt
Cadu Carvalho / Pexels

Ah yes, the Mr. Rogers look. The cardigan is an underrated hero in your wardrobe and when you wear it over a dress shirt, it can accomplish a lot of different goals. The first is it can dress up an otherwise plain button-up and chinos. The second is it can take the place of a sport coat or suit coat. Depending on what kind of cardigan you have, this is how you wear them over a dress shirt:

  • If it is a chunky cardigan, wear it with denim and a button-down collar to keep the whole look on the same level. If you want to elevate this look, opt for some luxury leather loafers or chelsea boots. If you want to keep it really casual, keep the cardigan open.
  • If it is a thin cardigan, use it the same way you would use a V-neck and wear it under a jacket and over a dress shirt and tie. You may want to keep this a solid in this situation too. Keep in mind two things: One, never button the bottom button, same as your vest. And two, if it is the same color as the tie but not the suit, it will look like a prom look, so be mindful of your coloring.

Wearing a sweater over a dress shirt is a timeless look and is the perfect way to add depth to your fall and winter wardrobe. Master the above and you will own the attention in the office or on the street.

Mark McKee
Mark is a full-time freelance writer and men's coach. He spent time as a style consultant and bespoke suit salesman before…
Dress like Rip Wheeler on the Yellowstone Ranch with Paramount shop
Paramount shop makes it easy to show your Yellowstone love
Yellowstone Denim logo

Some series hit the screens and spread globally like a virus. Cultural phenomena like Game of Thrones, Stranger Things, and Friends changed the cultural landscape and are spoken about at water coolers all across the 9-5s. Debates and fan theories run rampant even after they go off the air. Yellowstone is the newest member of this club, as the battle for the Dutton Ranch is the talk of the breakroom once again. With the return of Rip (Cole Hauser), Beth (Kelly Reilly), Jamie (Wes Bentley), and Kayce (Luke Grimes), you may be feeling the itch to discuss the show and show your love. The Paramount x Yellowstone collection allows you to dress like your favorite character on and off the ranch.
Little nods to loud statements

Let's be real here: one of the reasons Yellowstone made such a splash was because Cole Hauser is unapologetically rugged and manly as Rip Wheeler. His ability to be charming and at the same time usher problems to the train station caused men and women everywhere to swoon for five seasons. With the Paramount x Yellowstone collection, you can invest in the suitable garments and accessories to channel your inner Rip. From his black denim Yellowstone jacket to his aviators, just pop a toothpick in your mouth, and you will have people doing what you say when you say it in fear of a trip to the train station. Of course, you could also simply get some stickers or something to show your love for the series. The choice is yours.
Paramount Yellowstone Shop

Read more
Best men’s denim jackets: Handpicked for you
Add one these classics to your wardrobe
Man in all denim outfit

Few things are cooler in a man's wardrobe than a denim jacket. Whether you love the look that James Dean made famous or the Marlon Brando legend, denim jackets have been a mainstay in menswear for a century. While they were always used as workwear since Levi's started outfitting men in denim for the Gold Rush, they have now jumped from the goldmines to fashion when men began working against the grain and rebelling. Of course, since there are dozens of types and hundreds of brands to choose from, we make it our business to help you figure out what the best men's denim jackets.

Check out these choices for the best jean jackets to channel the Dean or the Brando.
DEVIL DOG DUNGAREES Thunderhead Trucker

Read more
Wardrobe update: The men’s fall sweaters you need to complete your look
Look great in sweaters this fall
Man in black jeans, sweater, and hat

As the fall continues to barrel us towards the darker months of winter (to be clear, we love the winter for the chance to wear our favorite jackets and coats, but the days are shorter), the weather reminds us that we need to upgrade our closets. While you can break out the heavier fabrics and start wearing your best lightweight jackets, one inescapable truth is that you must ensure you have a great sweater to get you through to spring. Of course, that means we get to go shopping and find all of our favorites (we shamelessly rise to this occasion with not a small amount of excitement). These are the ones we came up with.
Bugatchi Mixed Stitch Turtleneck Sweater

There is no better flex than mastering the style of turtlenecks. They are a classic men's staple and, therefore, should be something you figure out how to wear for yourself. While you do that, invest in the most high-quality and stylish options. There are a lot of them out there, but this one from Bugatchi is our favorite for the year. The chunky turtleneck will often be the statement piece, so it needs to speak. This one has a thunderous voice but somehow isn't overbearing.

Read more