Skip to main content

Pilates or weight training: Which is better for you?

These two workouts are similar, but there are key differences

Man doing Pilates with yoga blocks.
Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Did you know that Pilates and weight training can sculpt your body in unique ways to give you that fit look? 

In general, these exercises are designed to help build your body and keep you at the top of your fitness game. Pilates emphasizes the body’s flexibility and core strength, offering a dynamic approach to fitness, while weight training enhances endurance and muscle strength.

Recommended Videos

In this piece, we will go on a journey to unravel the components of these exercises, discovering which aligns best with your fitness goals.

Pilates or weight training? Let’s find out!

Woman doing Pilates.
Nicholas Fu / Pexels

What is the difference between Pilates and weight training?

Practicing Pilates and weight training are two ways to achieve a healthy and fit body. It is an excellent option for people who desire to work out using a particular modality of exercise plan that suits them.

Pilates, a series of exercises Joseph Hubertus Pilates created in the 1920s, helps to improve abdominal strength as well as total body and mental awareness. They include crisscross, toe taps, and plank rocks. Some of these exercises require a person to control their body motions with an emphasis on proper posture and positioning. 

Pilates is a famous low-impact workout that improves posture, muscle equilibrium, and coordination. However, unlike weight training, Pilates depends on body weight or resistance from specialized instruments such as Pilates reformers or resistance bands.

On the other hand, weight training involves an individual lifting some external weights such as dumbbells, a barbell, or a machine — this creates muscle resistance. Weight training aims at maximizing muscle size, strength, and stamina. It helps to build up muscles in specific areas of the body, which is essential because it allows for progressive overload, an important factor in gaining or building muscles.

The first major difference revolves around the form of resistance applied. Unlike weight lifting, Pilates uses controlled movements, and the bodyweight generates resistance, leading to a slim physique, i.e., no bulky muscles. In contrast, weight training uses external weights that challenge different resistance levels at muscle hyperplasia.

Additionally, Pilates differs from traditional weight training due to its focus on the body’s core. These exercises work the deep stabilizing muscles found inside the core so that one can have a steadfast center. However, weight training tends to involve the muscles in the small details, which Pilates focuses on, but not as keenly.

Man using Pilates reformer.
Kampus Production / Pexels

Why is Pilates growing in popularity?

Pilates is experiencing a surge in popularity, and several factors contribute to this fitness phenomenon. One Pilates innovative postural technique that has been developed is wall pilates. This new approach involving walls or vertical surfaces makes Pilates exercises interesting and poses a challenge to enthusiasts looking to experience a thrilling workout.

Further, the fact that you can do Pilates anywhere has played a vital role in promoting this fitness activity globally. Also, there are streaming sites and online classes that allow people to learn and practice Pilates at home with or without fitness equipment. This makes it easy for you to introduce it into your daily routine.

Additionally, Pilates is concerned with promoting total well-being. It entails mental concentration, breathing, flexibility, and physical exercise, making it a comprehensive health workout plan. As people place greater emphasis on well-being, Pilates comes in handy since it is the appropriate whole-body fitness exercise for individuals who seek such an approach.

Another factor driving Pilates’s popularity is its ability to be used across different fitness levels. It is so adaptable that beginner and advanced users can find it engaging and easy to perform. This versatility contributes to its widespread adoption as a preferred fitness regimen in today’s health-conscious culture.

a man in a wheelchair performing a biceps curl
Alesia Kozik / Pexels

How does weight training change your body?

Getting yourself into regular weight training can change your physiological and physical appearance, giving you that chiseled and healthy look. Here are different ways weight training can change your body:

Muscle growth

Muscle fiber hypertrophy occurs in response to weight training. This is because weight training strains the muscles, making the body repair them—consequently, the muscle fibers increase, which, in turn, increases muscle size. 

Increased strength

Regular weight or strength training improves the neuromuscular connection, increasing stamina. This heightens efficiency in recruiting muscles and their fibers during exercise, leading to greater force production.

Fat loss

The increased metabolic rate during weight training helps shred fat. The muscles involved in weight-based exercise burn calories even at rest because this tissue type is metabolically active.

Improved bone density

A form of weight training known as weight-bearing increases the rate of bone formation and strengthens the bones by making them dense. It is significant in guarding against osteoporosis and overall skeletal health.

Enhanced joint health

When done appropriately, weight training strengthens the muscles surrounding the joints, enhancing support and stability at joint sites. It is vital for injury prevention as well as arthritis.

Metabolic benefits

Weight training improves insulin sensitivity, glucose metabolism, and endocrine balance. However, these changes aid in general metabolic health, lowering the chances of having type 2 diabetes, among others.

Posture improvement

A critical effect of weight training is strengthening the muscles that control body alignment. This can help eliminate issues associated with bad posture and protect one from musculoskeletal conditions.

Elevated mood

There are several psychological benefits associated with weight training, one of them being endorphin release — the body’s natural mood elevators. Weight training regularly helps relieve stress, anxiety, depression, and other medical conditions.

Man doing Pilates at home.
Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

How does Pilates change your body?

Here are some ways Pilates can change your body:

Improved core strength

Core engagement is an important part of Pilates. You can perform these exercises on a mat or use specialized equipment such as a Pilates reformer, targeting deep abdominal muscles that enhance core strengthening and stability. Pilates for men and women in athletics improves their overall performance.

Muscle tone and definition

Pilates is a series of carefully defined and executed movements that stretch and strengthen numerous muscle systems. Therefore, it causes muscle toning, improving muscle definition without necessarily bulking.

Flexibility improvement

Practicing Pilates, such as wall Pilates and using a Pilates reformer, involves dynamic stretching for healthy joint and body movement. Improvement of flexibility entails lengthening muscles, making one less vulnerable to injuries. Also, it increases the possible range of motion.

Posture enhancement

Regular practice leads to the formation of better posture habits and an upright and aligned body frame.  

Mind-body connection

In Pilates, there is a focus on mindful movements where one tries to connect with the body. The emphasis on breath regulation heightens the level of attention, facilitating a more profound awareness of the body and mind system.

Stress reduction

Pilates is also involved with relaxation and breath control, which assist in reducing stress levels. It helps you relax and recharge your body from tension and stress associated with daily life.

Guy at a gym grabs a barbell to start a snatch exercise.
Victor Freitas / Unsplash

4 tips for deciding which is better for you

Consider your fitness goals

You should pick Pilates if your desire is for overall body flexibility, core strength, and a lean physique. However, weight training is preferable if you desire muscular hypertrophy, strength, or a more defined physique.

Preferable style of exercise 

Pilates is for you, should you prefer low-impact and controlled movements with the mind/body connection. Meanwhile, weight training is often preferred by people who enjoy the intensity of weights and putting their muscles under stress.

Consider your health 

Unlike weight training exercises, Pilates tends to be softer on the joints, which means that individuals with pre-existing joint problems and injuries can still practice Pilates. However, weight training should be modified; in some cases, you may have to consult your doctor before practice.

Your personal enjoyment and consistency 

Participating in a Pilates class may be interesting if you love and enjoy group settings. However, if the idea of lifting weights and keeping track of performance excites you, then it might make more sense for you to try weight training in a gym setting.

You should pick Pilates or weight training based on your preferences, fitness objectives, body condition, and the pleasure involved in them. Also, you can combine the best aspects of these two approaches to create a more balanced fitness regimen. Do not hesitate to seek the advice of your doctor or fitness coach if you have any concerns about your health and exercises.

Christine VanDoren
Christine is a certified personal trainer and nutritionist with an undergraduate degree from Missouri State University. Her…
How to lose belly fat: Eating these 10 foods more often will help a lot
Diet won't do it all, but we bet you need to make a few tweaks
Man holding belly fat

As a trainer and nutritionist, I constantly have clients approach me, sharing that they want nothing more than to get rid of their stubborn belly fat. Many people hold excess weight in the abdominal area, so if this sounds like you, you are not alone. Unfortunately, you cannot target fat on any part of your body. However, being consistent with healthy habits can make you burn fat throughout your body, including in your belly.

Many people think simply going to the gym will make enough of a difference, but it's actually nutrition that will deliver the majority of your results. Keep reading to learn what foods to add to your grocery list to better understand how to lose belly fat with diet.
Edamame

Read more
Work every muscle with this complete full-body dumbbell workout — no gym needed
Increase your VO2 max, build muscle, burn fat, and torch calories with this full-body dumbbell workout
Man laying on workout bench doing chest presses with dumbbells

You can work your whole body from the comfort and privacy of home with a pair of dumbbells. While gym machines, kettlebells, resistance bands, and other gym equipment definitely have their benefits and uses, sometimes keeping it simple with two dumbbells is the way to go.

My first home workout equipment was a humble yoga mat and a pair of adjustable dumbbells. It allowed me to ease my way into it. A full-body dumbbell workout is an efficient way to fire up all of your major muscle groups, which is excellent news for those of us with a busy schedule. Let’s look at the ultimate full-body dumbbell workout and the benefits of using dumbbells.
The benefits of using dumbbells in your workout

Read more
Does the air quality really impact your marathon finish time? What to know
Researchers used an advanced model of particulate matter to analyze pollution at every mile along the marathon route.
marathon people finishing finish line running

Since the Clean Air Act of 1970, air quality has greatly improved in the United States, and people are increasingly concerned about the environment and the air we breathe. Sensitive ecosystems are damaged by air pollution, and related illnesses take a toll on the healthcare system. If air quality affects human health, does it also affect marathon finish time for runners?

Runners prepare for marathons in different ways, such as eating a nutrient-dense diet and practicing tempo runs and interval runs. Certain factors impact how long it takes for you to cross that finish line, but what about the air quality? Recently, researchers conducted a study to find out more. Let’s zoom in on the research and results.
The study

Read more