Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

What is the Optavia diet and does it work?

Learn the pros and cons of this diet method

Meatloaf slices with metal fork on a towel with "Optavia" below it.
Optavia / Facebook

With so many people looking to improve their health and lose weight, numerous diet techniques have been created and publicized. Each one claims to be the one that will make a difference for you, so it is hard to know what is true. You may have tried to simply “eat healthier” but need more guidance to see real change.

This is where the Optavia diet could come in. So, what is the Optavia diet? It is a meal replacement plan and home delivery system that takes all the thinking out of dieting for you. Keep reading to learn more about how it works, as well as the pros and cons.

Recommended Videos

What is the Optavia diet?

Person measuring waist
Alamy

The Optavia diet is based on a caloric-deficit, low-carb, programmed home delivery service that also has personalized coaching to help you lose weight. It offers its “Fuelings” in pre-packaged form as well as entree-based “Lean and Green” meals — lean protein options with non-starchy veggies and healthy fats.

The plans

Boxes of Optavia fuelings and their respective finished products on a surface.
Optavia / YouTube

Optavia offers a couple of different plans based on your individual needs and personal goals. Here is what they offer:

  • Optimal Weight 5&1 Plan – The most popular plan, this version includes five Optavia Fuelings and one Lean and Green meal each day.
  • Optimal Weight 4&2&1 Plan – For those who need more calories or flexibility in food choices, this plan includes four Optavia Fuelings, two Lean and Green meals, and one additional snack per day.
  • Optimal Health 3&3 Plan – This plan is designed for maintenance. It includes three Optavia Fuelings and three balanced Lean and Green meals per day.

How it works

A close-up of a sheet pan shrimp scampi.
Optavia / Facebook

By selecting the plan that fits your goals and lifestyle, the Optavia diet tries establishing one lifelong healthy habit at a time in order to make this a lifestyle change. The first goal is achieving a healthy weight, which hopefully leads to healthier habits, like those listed below:

  • Nutrition
  • Sleep
  • Movement
  • Hydration

Meal plans are based around six meals per day, eating every 2 to 3 hours.

Pros of the Optavia diet

A close-up of a bagel sandwich on brown paper on a table.
Optavia / Facebook
  • Weight loss – Focusing on putting the client in a caloric deficit will result in overall initial weight loss.
  • Personal 1-on-1 coaching – Any diet can have a caloric deficit for weight loss, but the additional help of an actual coach to help teach mindful habits can be very beneficial with the added bonus of extra accountability.
  • Easy to follow – The diet is a home-based food delivery service that keeps it simple depending on which plan you are doing and makes sticking with it easy. No need to track or count, just reheat and eat.

Cons of the Optavia diet

Three mushroom bun sliders with cheese, tomatoes, and lettuce on a rectangular plate on a circular wooden tray.
Optavia / Facebook
  • Long-term success rate – A 2017 study found that “commercial weight-loss programs consistently fail to produce modest but clinically meaningful weight loss with high rates of attrition, suggesting that many clients find dietary changes required by these programs unsustainable for long-term goals.”
  • Sales pressure and costly – Just like any type of delivery service, there are additional costs for delivery and convenience. Then, there’s the whole added sales pitch built into the system as well.
  • Highly processed  – Any type of food that is prepackaged is going to be processed, which can lead to chronic inflammation and gut health issues.
  • Long-term sustainability – Following Optavia’s most popular plan, the 5&1, an individual would consume roughly 800-1200 calories on average per day. That is not sustainable for most men in the long term. Great for initial weight loss but extremely worrisome with significant muscle loss.

Our take

Arroz con pollo served on a plate on a table with "Optavia" at the bottom right corner.
Optavia / Facebook

While the diet does seem ideal for time efficiency and is definitely better than consuming McDonald’s three times a week, there is still plenty of room for improvement. The best diets are ones that have long-term success, don’t restrict food intake drastically, and have a much more well-rounded approach.

If you want an even better place to start, check out our take on some of the best diets available right now and see which one is best for you. Hint: They are the ones that have been around for decades and are sustainable long-term.

Frequently asked questions

Box of condiments
igorovsyannykov / Pixabay

Are condiments allowed on the Optavia diet?

Yes, specific condiments are allowed to help you spice up your meals. However, they need to be very low in calories to be compliant. You can have spices, herbs, lemon juice, lime juice, vinegar, mustard, and salsa. You want to avoid sauces like ranch, barbecue sauce, and mayonnaise, as the calories can add up quickly, and added sugars are often included as well.

Can you drink alcohol while following the Optavia diet?

Drinking alcohol is not recommended while you are on the Optavia diet. This is true with nearly every weight loss program, as alcohol can slow down progress. It contains empty calories and sugars that can quickly put you in a calorie surplus. If you do choose to drink anyway, try to stick with low-calorie spirits like vodka and tequila, as these contain less than 100 calories per shot.

Jeff Turbett
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jeff Turbett is a health and wellness coach with over three years of experience transforming clients lives and physical…
Can you mix creatine with coffee? Here’s the truth
Discover whether caffeine alters creatine's effectiveness
Coffee cup on a saucer

Creatine is a popular athletic supplement that improves muscle health and exercise performance. If you’re bringing creatine into your workout routine, you might have questions about its interactions or what you can take it with. As a trainer and nutritionist, I am a fan of the supplement and recommend it to many clients looking to take things up a notch.

However, some common myths about creatine are being passed around without any scientific sources, like the idea that mixing creatine with coffee will reduce its effectiveness. Is that fact or fiction? Truth or myth? We’ll dive into the evidence today to help you figure out whether you can take creatine with your morning coffee or not.
What are the benefits of taking creatine?

Read more
Why are runners everywhere doing a gait analysis? What are the benefits?
A gait analysis doesn't just help you pick out the best running shoes
legs running on track.

A gait analysis isn’t just for beginners and those looking to buy their first pair of running shoes; more runners everywhere are using it as a tool to expand their running abilities and improve speed and performance. A gait analysis can be valuable for beginners and experienced runners alike. Runners frequently adjust training methods to boost performance; a gait analysis could be a key component you’re missing.
What is a gait analysis?

A gait analysis is a way of examining your running gait, which refers to the movements or motions that make up your running technique. All running styles are different, but if you have a bad technique, you’re more likely to get injured, and your speed could be hampered.

Read more
What is ‘couch to 5K’ and should you try it?
As they say, a thousand-mile journey begins with a single step.
men running in marathon with US flag rainy

Most of us have heard of the ‘couch to 5K’, and it certainly sounds promising for beginners as a method of training to help get you up off the couch and crossing the 5K finish line. Research highlights that a sedentary lifestyle increases the risk of cancer, cardiovascular disease, metabolic diseases, and more. 

Being inactive and not getting enough exercise is associated with worse health outcomes when it comes to heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and cancer. Couch to 5K is one of the popular methods to help beginners become more active and get the benefits of running by gradually making their way to completing a full 5K. As they say, a thousand-mile journey begins with a single step. Let’s look at the couch to 5k method and the potential benefits.
What is a 5K?

Read more