Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

The best oil for searing steak (and what not to use)

Put down the butter and walk away

By

Whether it’s an incredibly succulent ribeye, a tender, juicy bone-in pork chop, or a crisped-to-perfection grilled chicken thigh, we all strive to achieve that golden crisp crust when cooking our favorite proteins. But getting that perfect bite comes with a bit of know-how, like how long to cook your food, how to make the perfect marinade, how long to let your food rest after it’s been cooked, and what cooking oils to use.

If you’ve ever inadvertently over-charred a steak or set off the smoke alarm in your kitchen, the oil you used in your recipe may be to blame. If so, keep reading to find out what the best oil for searing steak is.

Recommended Videos

Understanding smoke points

Steak frying in a pan
bnenin / Adobe Stock

You may have heard the term “smoke point” before, be it in a recipe or when talking to someone with some culinary chops. The term is really just a fancy way of indicating the temperature at which an oil starts to burn and become gross. Because we like to cook things like steak at high temperatures to achieve a delicious sear, it’s important to cook with oils that have higher smoke points so that we can cook our food without burning the outside.

Related

Different oils have different smoke points, and knowing which oil will make your steak delicious and which will turn it into a bitterly burnt disaster is an important skill to have.

Is it better to sear steaks with butter or olive oil?

It pains us to admit this because we’re fans of butter. Big fans. Sadly, though, butter is one of the worst choices for searing steak due to its extremely low smoke point of about 350 degrees Fahrenheit. If butter alone is used for searing, it’s likely to burn and give a bitter flavor to whatever you’re cooking. But there is good news for those of us who are big on butter. Butter can most certainly be used in the searing process when paired with another oil that has a high smoke point. Simply sear your ingredient in another oil before basting it with added butter for a tender and absolutely delicious bite.

Olive oil is also a tremendously popular ingredient in most of our kitchens. Unfortunately, though, it too falls a bit short when it comes to searing. Extra virgin olive oil begins to smoke at about 350 degrees Fahrenheit, making it just as bad as butter when it comes to avoiding a burnt mess. While regular olive oil has a slightly higher range of about 390 to 430 degrees Fahrenheit, it’s better to use another oil to be on the safe side. It’s also worth noting that olive oil has a very distinct flavor of, well, olives. While this is favored in raw oil preparations like salad dressings and finishing oils, it isn’t always desired on seared foods like steak or chicken.

What is the best oil for pan-searing steak?

There are many oils with high smoke points that are wonderful for creating a beautifully golden sear on whatever ingredient you happen to be cooking. Canola oil has an average smoke point of about 430 degrees Fahrenheit, which makes it a very popular choice in both restaurant and at-home kitchens. The mild flavors of canola are also great when you’re looking to add a sear but not necessarily flavor from the oil itself. Avocado oil and grapeseed oil also have high smoke points, making them great alternatives to vegetable or canola oil.

Is avocado oil better than grapeseed oil for searing?

If you’re looking to cook something on a high sear, both avocado and grapeseed oils are good choices. Avocado oil, depending on the brand and quality, can have a smoke point up to 520 degrees Fahrenheit, giving it an extremely high smoke point, which is ideal for high-heat cooking.

Grapeseed oil has a good smoke point, averaging about 420 degrees Fahrenheit, but it also has a more substantial flavor than avocado oil, which may overwhelm the ingredient you’re searing. If you don’t like the flavor of any particular oil, it’s usually best to avoid cooking with it.

Smoke points of popular cooking oils

  • Avocado oil: 480 to 520 Fahrenheit
  • Safflower oil: 450 to 500 Fahrenheit
  • Canola oil: 400 to 475 Fahrenheit
  • Soybean oil: 450 Fahrenheit
  • Sunflower oil: 450 Fahrenheit
  • Peanut oil: 450 Fahrenheit
  • Coconut oil: 400 to 450 Fahrenheit
  • Grapeseed oil: 420 Fahrenheit

Editors’ Recommendations

Topics
Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay Parrill
Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
Discover Rome’s best-kept secret with the Negroni Formidabile
A shot of Roman amaro adds an anise kick to the classic cocktail
Amaro Formidabile

On a recent trip to Rome, I discovered something wonderful. Not the stunning architecture or the beautiful art, or the incredible history of the Roman Forum -- though those are pretty great too -- but a new to me amaro called Amaro Formidabile. The amaro is handmade in Rome, using a long list of botanicals including cinchona, wormwood, gentian, kola nut, star anise, and more, and it has all the fruity sweetness of something like Montenegro, but with a solid bitter backbone more reminiscent of Fernet.

What I like best about it though is the strong punch of anise that rushes to the front, making it almost reminiscent of Ouzo, but without the harshness and with more fruity, floral flavors supporting in the background. The Romans love to drink this amaro simply: just chilled, or perhaps over ice, but sipped alone after a meal as a tasty digestif. It's a great way to see off a delicious, indulgent Roman meal of artichokes with pecorino romano, stuffed courgette flowers or fiori di zucca, then a big hearty bowl of cacio e pepe.

Read more
Can you microwave coffee? What you should know about proper reheating
Don't dump cold coffee just yet
Man drinking a cup of coffee

Imagine this: You've managed to make it out of bed, head downstairs, and patiently await a freshly brewed cup of coffee as you turn on your coffee maker. You take the first deliciously warm sip and place your mug down. Soon, your attention is quickly on the next thing on your to-do list, whether getting ready for work or unloading the dishwasher. Before you know it, an hour has passed, and you realize your warm cup of coffee is still sitting there, mostly full and cold. This common occurrence may leave you wondering: "Can you microwave coffee?"
Can you microwave coffee?

Instead of wasting a cup of cold coffee, you can reheat your room-temperature coffee in the microwave. However, if you've ever done this, you may notice that the coffee tastes different once reheated. Microwaving your coffee causes it to become more bitter, thanks to the natural acids within coffee. Chlorogenic acid, caffeic acid, and quinic acid are all present when you initially brew your coffee. Yet, these compounds are released even more when you reheat your cup. In turn, you may be left with more bitter coffee than the original cup. If you can get past the slight changes in taste, your coffee is still safe to consume even after reheating.
How to reheat coffee in the microwave

Read more
The top beef cuts for braising: Elevate your cooking game
It's time to get cozy
Beef bourguignon

Autumn is my favorite season for cooking. Sure, I love summertime grilling and gorgeously vibrant spring vegetables, but there's just something special about warm and spicy, comforting fall and wintertime dishes. Braising, specifically, is perhaps the coziest way to cook. There's something magical about the way an hours-long braise fills your home with the promise of a delicious meal, the satisfyingly familiar scent, and taste of a dish that's become associated with fall in your home. In my house, braised beef dishes are some of these meals. From boeuf bourguignon to braised beef shank with the best red wine and mushrooms, there are few dishes as satisfying as braised beef.

There's actually a scientific reason these dishes are among the most comforting and satisfying meals to make. During the long cooking time at low temperatures, collagen in beef turns to gelatin, which is what gives braised beef dishes and their broth such a rich and velvety flavor and mouthfeel.

Read more