Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

The best porters to drink this fall

Autumn is here, so it's time to pour a porter

Porter beer in a glass
Impact Photography / Shutterstock

While early fall isn’t exactly cold, it’s only a matter of time before the days begin to grow shorter and the nights start getting cooler. That’s why autumn is such a great time to get into dark beers. Specifically, stouts and porters. But while both beers are dark in color and rich and robust in flavor, what exactly is the difference between the two beer styles? Both originated in England in the 1700s and are known for their chocolate, smooth, creamy flavor profiles. But they are subtly different.

Porters are made with malted barley and stouts are usually brewed with unmalted roasted barley. This is why porters are often sweet and creamier, with a ton of chocolate and dried fruit flavors. The stout, on the other hand, is often drier with a ton of roasted barley flavor along with chocolate, coffee, and other flavors. While stouts can be quite decadent, porters are usually overall lighter, thus making them a great choice for early fall drinking. Keep reading to find out what the best porter beers are to enjoy this autumn.

Recommended Videos

The best classic porters for fall

Sniffing a stout in a glass
monica di loxley / Unsplash

Now that you’ve learned a little bit about the differences between stouts and porters, it’s time to find some to drink this fall. Lucky for you, there are countless award-winning options available. Below, you’ll find some of our favorite sweet, malty, well-balanced porters. Keep scrolling to see them all.

Anchor Porter

Anchor porter with cookies
Anchor

What didn’t Anchor help establish when it comes to American craft beer? Wanting to make a European-style beer when there were fewer than 100 breweries in America, Fritz Maytag settled on the English porter. Still made just how it first was in 1972, Anchor Porter presents much less roast characteristics than a modern porter and is highlighted by a dark fruitiness. It goes great with sweets, as seen above.

Deschutes Black Butte Porter

Deschutes Black Butte Porter
Deschutes

For a brewery now pushing out some of the finest mass-produced IPAs in the country, it can be odd to remember that Black Butte (along with Mirror Pond Pale Ale) is how the Oregon company, now over 30 years old, built its name. Chocolately, light-bodied, and less roasty than some of its contemporaries (and certainly fruitier), these characteristics are what made Black Butte Porter an approachable flagship beer.

Founders Porter

Founders Porter
Founders

Founders is known for some of its big dark beers full of bold flavors, like KBS and Breakfast Stout, but it is beers like Founders Porter that helped build the Grand Rapids brewery into what it is today. Renowned for most of its other beers, few beers provide such a clear stylistic example as this porter, which is full of chocolate and coffee and balanced by a nice hop bitterness. A word to the wise: Founders Porter is far more robust than the first two on the list.

Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter

Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter
Great Lakes Brewing Co.

Named after the famed ship that sank in Lake Superior in 1975, Edmund Fitzgerald is one of the fantastic beers made by Cleveland’s Great Lakes Brewing Company and is without a doubt a classic American porter. Edmund Fitzgerald is, in terms of roast malt level, the most intense of our four porters on offer. The beer is sharp and nutty, but with a bit more bitterness than even Founders. Still, it’s incredibly smooth and drinkable. It’s an annual tradition for many to crack one on the November 10 anniversary of the ship’s sinking while listening to Gordon Lightfoot’s song about the fateful journey.

Bottom line

Pouring a stout beer
Aaron Doucett / Unsplash

If you usually head right to stouts when the leaves start falling in autumn, you’re missing out on a more appropriate beer style. Porters, with their lighter body and balanced, sweet, flavor palate, are perfectly suited for fall weather. You know, when the season doesn’t know whether it’s still summer or heading headfirst into winter.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Stranahan’s releases a new whiskey to pay tribute to the American single malt designation
Stranahan’s celebrates the American single malt designation with a new whiskey
Stranahan’s

You might have read (on this website) about American single malt whiskey finally becoming a designated category. To celebrate this monumental achievement in the world of American whiskey, the distillers at Stranahan’s, maker of the US’ top-selling American single malt whiskey, announced the release of a limited-edition expression.
Stranahan’s Founders Release

It’s called Stranahan’s Founders Release and it’s limited-edition, 120-proof American single malt whiskey that was made with a mash bill of 100% malted barley and matured for twelve years in new, charred American white oak barrels before being finished in casks the once held bourbon and blonde ale.

Read more
You know what the world needs more of? Warm gin cocktails
Gin is overlooked when it comes to winter drinks, but this recipe challenges that
Citadelle

We love the trend for warm cocktails here, with the colder months in full swing and any excuse to get cozy feeling especially welcome during the dark, bleak months of January. And if you want a warm cocktail, there are plenty of options -- from the classic Hot Toddy, to fun toddy variations, to seasonal favorites like mulled wine or warm eggnog. You see lots of warm cocktails featuring classic winter spirits like whiskey, bourbon, or dark rum, and you'll find those which incorporate flavors like calvados, sherry, and even tequila and mezcal.

But you know what you almost never see in warm cocktails? Gin. And as a dedicated gin fan, I think that's a real shame. Admittedly, with its clear appearance and herbal, juniper flavors, gin isn't the most obvious choice for something cozy. I can't really picture mixing it with sweet flavors like hot chocolate, and adding it to mulled wine seems like a recipe for a hangover. But I do believe there's a way to make use of gin's delicious flavors, and the brand Citadelle has a suggestion which intrigues me: to use it in a Hot Toddy.

Read more
NYC bars are ringing in Dry January with these fruity, complex mocktails
See how these trendy cocktail bars are embracing the no-alcohol wave
BeefBar_AlexStaniloff_112124-022

With so many people getting on board for Dry January, cocktail bars around the world and getting in on the non-alcoholic action too. Two NYC bars have embraced this trend with challenging, interesting mocktails which keep the sensory pleasures of a cocktail but ditch the booze.

“As a teenager who grew up in Flatbush, Brooklyn my preparation for my driver's test involved two traditions-- practicing my K turns on the slow cobblestoned streets of Red Hook Brooklyn and grabbing a celebratory slice of Steve's Key Lime Pie for not crashing!" said Rob Giles of Beefbar NYC, creator of one of the drinks. "This non- alcoholic cocktail is an homage to that using coconut cream, Thai coconut milk, and topped with Fever Tree lime and yuzu soda.”
Indo Colada from Wayan NYC

Read more