Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

291 Single Barrel Colorado Rye Whiskey Review

By

Located in Colorado Springs, Distillery 291 was born when New York City fashion photographer Michael Myers realized he needed to get out of dodge. That was 2011. Since opening, Distillery 291 has produced five kinds of whiskey (a bourbon, unaged rye, an American whiskey mellowed with Aspen charcoal, and an unaged corn whiskey), as well as a citrus clove whisky liqueur.

Related:

Recommended Videos

What separates this rye whiskey from other rye whiskies on the market is the finish. Where some whiskies (like Maker’s 46, for example) may finish with French oak, a common type of wood used in liquor-making, Distillery 291 finishes their Colorado Rye Whiskey with aspen staves — which, coming from Colorado seems appropriate.

Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Appearance: Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey shines bright like a new penny.

Related

Nose: The rye spice characteristics come through first and foremost, and these are rounded out by notes of cooked fruit and fruit cake. A hint of pine can also be found mixed in there.

Palate: A beery, sweet malty flavor is one of the most prevalent you will get upon first sip. It is bright and almost effervescent, leading you into baking spices and caramel that remind you that you’re working with a rye whiskey aged in new barrels. There is a certain heat on the back end, due to both the age of the whiskey (less than two years) and the high proof (101.7).

Finish: As we get near the holiday season, the finish on this whiskey seems appropriate, as it tastes very Christmas-y. You’ll get nutmeg and cinnamon mixing with a cedar woodiness. The flavors linger on the palate for a while.

Final thoughts: For a young whiskey, this is more enjoyable than many I’ve had. I’m curious to see what these whiskies would taste like once they’ve got a few more years in barrels. The real hang-up for most will be the price — at around $70 per bottle, it might be hard for some to justify splurging on a whiskey that is so young. However, we think if you appreciate well-made whiskey (and you have the money to spend), it’s worth giving it a try. It’s a whiskey that is good for putting in a flask and going camping in order to brave those cold mountain nights, or for using in a rye whiskey cocktail, as the flavor and proof will stand up to other ingredients.

Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey is 50.8 percent ABV and retails for around $70.

Feature image courtesy of Distillery 291/Facebook.

Editors’ Recommendations

Topics
Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Kentucky’s New Riff Distillery Has Released a Peated Bourbon and Rye
New Riff Distillery

New Riff is a newcomer to the Kentucky whiskey scene, but has made quite a name for itself already. The bourbon and rye it distills are both bottled-in-bond, meaning they are at least four years old and bottled at 100 proof. The mash bill for the bourbon is high-rye (65% corn, 30% rye, 5% malted barley) while the rye is 100% rye (with 5% malted rye). The latest additions to the lineup are two whiskeys called Backsetter, a bourbon and a rye that use peated malt in their production. The whiskey is also bottled-in-bond and not chill filtered. New Riff co-founder Jay Erisman said that this project came about back in 2015 in a sort of understated fashion. "I wish I could say there was some grand, overarching strategy to make an absolutely unprecedented whiskey," he said, "but really it was a matter of a creative, intrepid team of distillers at a young distillery determined to make a new riff on an old tradition. Backsetter is a collision of old and new; a cover tune, perhaps of a Scottish Hebridean reel filtered (or rather, unfiltered) through Kentucky bluegrass and a Marshall stack."

The name Backsetter is really just a reference to the classic Kentucky sour mash process, where a portion of the stillage left over from distillation is added to the next batch, kind of like a sourdough starter. "We strain off a portion of the stillage, and 'set it back' to add into the next mash," said Erisman. "This is called (in old time Kentucky distilling parlance), 'backset.' Some 25 percent of the liquid content of a mash consists of backset. What makes these Backsetter whiskeys so unique is the nature of that backset: it was from a peated malted barley distillation."

Read more
Classic Old Overholt Rye Whiskey Gets an Upgrade
old overholt rye whiskey update

Old Overholt is a classic, inexpensive rye whiskey that has been a favorite of bartenders and home drinkers for years. Originally a Pennsylvania rye that got its start in the early 1800s, the brand was acquired by Jim Beam back in 1987 and for decades has been a young (around three years old) 80 proof barely legal rye, with a mash bill containing around 51% rye, that is distilled in Kentucky. The low ABV has been a sticking point for some, especially when going up against the similarly aged and priced, but 100 proof, Rittenhouse Rye. This might have been a factor leading to the release of Old Overholt Bottled in Bond a few years ago, which upped the proof to 100 as required by the Bottled in Bond Act. But now Old Overholt is changing up a few key features of the whiskey in a way that seems like a positive development for longtime fans of this workhorse rye.

“Old Overholt is an incredibly resilient brand that has stood the test of time for three reasons," said Tim Heuisler, American Whisk(e)y Ambassador for Beam Suntory in a prepared statement. "It’s always been a quality whiskey, it’s embraced its own evolution throughout history, and it’s consistently been affordable. These updates will only better serve the bar community that first adopted Overholt years ago. We’re taking the trusted, quality whiskey that we all know and love and making mindful improvements to help it stand out even more as a cornerstone of American Rye.”

Read more
The Shed Distillery launches Drumshanbo Tawny Port Cask Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
The Shed Distillery is releasing a Tawny Port-aged whiskey
The Shed Distillery

We seem to say this a lot lately, but there’s another Irish whiskey to get excited about before St. Patrick’s Day next month. That’s because The Shed Distillery is set to launch a new Drumshanbo Irish whiskey aged in Tawny Port barrels.
Drumshanbo Tawny Port Cask Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

The award-winning Shed Distillery is launching Drumshanbo Tawny Port Cask Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey, a special and rare limited-release expression. This Irish whiskey begins with a mash bill featuring malted Irish barley, unmalted Irish barley, and Irish Barra oats. It’s triple distilled and matured for seven years in Tawny Port casks.

Read more