Skip to main content

The fall martini: How to put a seasonal twist on a classic

Fall is a time for a whiskey-based martini

Manhattan
Heleno Viero / iStock

If you were to make a list of iconic, classic cocktails, the martini would make the cut. While there are many stories about its genesis, it’s believed by many that famed writer and bartender Jerry Thomas created the martini in the mid to late 1800s at the Occidental Hotel in San Francisco. Whether this is its true origin story, it’s still a timeless classic drink that remains popular today.

If you’re not a big drinker, you might assume that the martini is made with vodka. In fact, if you use vodka as the base for the drink, it must be referred to as a vodka martini. The original martini consists simply of London dry gin, vermouth, and perhaps a lemon twist or olive garnish. It’s simple, elegant, and the perfect way to drink gin.

Recommended Videos

And while nobody is going to argue about its popularity, is it the best option for fall imbibing? Sure, it’s boozy and warming, but is there a way to change it up enough to make it a fall seasonal drink? And no, we aren’t talking about adding pumpkin spice flavor to it to make it a fall martini.

Changing up the martini for fall

Fall martini
ArtMarie / iStock

Obviously, the classic martini is made with gin, but we prefer to enjoy gin-based drinks during the warmer months. We’re all about whiskey when autumn rolls around. That’s why we’re going to enjoy a riff on the classic drink made with whiskey instead.

Similar to a Manhattan, our fall martini is going to have a base of rye whiskey (or bourbon) instead of the usual herbal and botanical gin or neutral vodka found in a martini. But while a Manhattan is made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters, we’re keeping with the martini tradition and using whiskey, dry vermouth, simple syrup, and Peychaud’s bitters. Keep scrolling to see how to make this warming, autumn cocktail.

What you need to make the fall martini

  • 2 ounces of rye whiskey (or bourbon if you prefer more corn sweetness to peppery spice)
  • 1 ounce of dry vermouth
  • 1/2 ounce of simple syrup
  • 2-3 dashes of Peychaud’s bitters

The fall martini recipe steps

1. In an ice-filled mixing glass, add rye whiskey, dry vermouth, simple syrup, and Peychaud’s bitters.
2. Stir gently to combine and chill all of the ingredients.
3. Strain into a chilled martini glass.
4. Garnish with a cocktail cherry.

Bottom line

Whiskey bottles
Adam Wilson / Unsplash

If you’re not about pumpkin spice and you’d prefer your cocktail boozy and loaded with whiskey as opposed to coffee, this is the fall drink for you. It’s simple and easy to make and guaranteed to warm you from the inside out. If you already enjoy the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and other whiskey-based classic cocktails, you’ll love this whiskey-fied take on the traditional martini.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Use this genius flavor wheel for perfect martinis every time
This flavor wheel will steer you to the perfect vermouth and bitter partners for your gin
perfect martini flavor wheel botanist hot toddy jpg

Creating the perfect martini is a real art form. While there are plenty who love the classic version of the drink -- just gin, with a tiny whiff of dry vermouth, stirred together and perhaps garnished with an olive -- there are also millions of martini variations incorporating just about every flavor and liqueur you can imagine. While purists might decry drinks like the Espresso Martini as not a martini at all (which I might have to agree with -- though it is a fine drink, it isn't really a martini) there are still variations you can make which keep within the bounds of tradition.

The key to a good martini variation is understanding your base spirit. With gin, you'll find a wide range of botanicals used which give a big range of flavors to the final product. So you need to identify the key flavors of your gin, and use that to pick your vermouth and your bitters.

Read more
Say farewell to the festive season with these gin cocktails
Enjoy a last festive drink before we all go back to work
festive gin cocktails flip  twitter 1

With the major holiday days down, and the new year already underway, most of us willing be closing up the holiday festivities and soon returning to work. But before you take down your Christmas tree or put away the decorations for another year, there's time to see off the festive period in style with some finely crafted cocktails.

For this time of year you want something simple, unfussy, and delicious, and that's just what these recipes from Nolet's Silver Gin offer. Nolet's is one of our favorite floral gins, with botanicals including rose, peach, and raspberry, and it can has a clean taste and smooth texture so it goes perfectly in simple cocktails alongside ingredients like cranberries, peppermint, and orgeat, ideal to see off the festive times.
Holiday Gin + Soda

Read more
Learn how to master the Coquito cocktail with these great recipes
Want to drink like they do in Puerto Rico? Mix up a Coquito, or little coconut, with these great recipes
Coquito cocktails

When it comes to holiday drinks, you have your classic choices like eggnog, and I often reach for a warm winter cocktail like an Irish coffee. But in Puerto Rico there's another drink that embodies the taste of the season: the Coquito.

While people most often drink it around Christmas, this sweet drink is suitable for any time of year, and it'll be a hit with anyone who loves a delicious dessert cocktail. It's perfect for the cool winter evenings when I want something cozy, creamy, and satisfying to sip on as I huddle down against the snowy weather. So this year, why not try a Coquito cocktail instead of an eggnog?
What is a Coquito?

Read more