Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

How to choose the healthiest beef: Grass-fed, grass-finished, or grain-fed

Differences in cooking, flavor, and more

ButcherBox doorstep
ButcherBox

The terms “grass-fed” or “grass-finished” are often seen on beef packaging and labels — but do you know what these terms truly mean? Choosing grass-fed or grass-finished beef over grain-fed beef offers exceptional health benefits due to higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids, antioxidants, and other vitamins like vitamin E and vitamin A. However, there are quite a few other differences between grass-fed beef, grain-finished beef, and grain-fed beef that are worth noting.

To learn more, I chatted with Ashley Lonsdale, chef-in-residence of the meat subscription box, ButcherBox, to compare grass-fed vs. grass-finished vs. grain-fed beef.

Recommended Videos

Lonsdale, a graduate of the French Culinary Institute, has spent years as a private chef, line cook in top New York City kitchens, and culinary director for food brands like Daily Harvest. Today, she works as part of the ButcherBox team to encourage consumers to cook more nutritious meals through approachable recipes and useful hints for home cooks.

In addition to her work at ButcherBox, Lonsdale has a true hunger for helping and inspiring others to build a love of cooking from a young age. She serves on the junior board of the Food Education Fund, a nonprofit supporting culinary-focused public high school students in New York City. Her newsletter, FOODSTAR, is full of cooking advice and easy recipes.

So, what exactly should you know when shopping for grass-fed vs. grass-finished vs. grain-fed beef? Here’s what Chef Lonsdale says shoppers should know to help elevate their dinners.

Do grass-fed, grass-finished, and grain-fed meats cook differently?

ButcherBox ribeye uncooked beef
ButcherBox

Grass-fed, grass-finished beef is often praised for its health benefits, but Lonsdale wants meat eaters to understand how each cooks, too. “Since grass-fed beef has less fat than grain-fed beef, it cooks about 30% faster,  she said. “The faster cooking time is an essential distinction for cuts of beef that require precision, like steaks.”

“When preparing grass-fed steak, I aim for about 5-10 degrees lower than a grain-fed steak. An instant-read thermometer is an excellent tool to add precision to your cooking. As with any protein, beef continues cooking once removed from direct heat, so plan to pull it slightly before reaching your desired internal temperature.”

Not only do grass-fed, grass-finished steaks cook faster, but many also find the taste to differ. Per Lonsdale, “Grass-fed beef is — to put it simply — beefier. It’s earthy and intense, and I enjoy the flavor depth. Although it is leaner than grain-fed alternatives, I still find my favorite cuts, like a ribeye, equally rich and satisfying.”

As other chefs from ButcherBox mention, grass-fed cattle graze on grass for most of their lives. However, they are fed grain at the end of their lives. This means that a grass-fed meat product is also considered “grain-finished meat.” Feeding cattle grain at the end of their lives gives the final product “a rich, buttery marbling.” Conversely, grass-finished cattle consume grass for their entire lives and are never given grains. This results in a slightly leaner flavor, with Lonsdale’s description of a more “earthy” flavor. The choice between which to consume comes down to personal taste preferences and your health and nutrition goals.

Grass-fed vs. grass-finished vs. grain-fed beef

ButcherBox ribeye
ButcherBox

Lonsdale stressed the importance of thoroughly reading labels when shopping for beef in our discussion. “The label grass-finished is different than just grass-fed. Grass-finished means the pastured cattle ate nothing but grass their entire lives. Often, the benefits of 100% grass-finished beef include higher levels of heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids and higher levels of other nutrients.

Not only is opting for higher-quality meat a health-conscious decision, but it is a more ethical one. As explained by Mulvey Gulch Ranch, there are fewer negative environmental impacts when selecting grass-fed, grass-finished beef, and increased animal welfare is at the “forefront of the grass-fed cattle ranchers’ goals.”

“I feel good about choosing grass-fed and grass-finished beef for the added benefits of higher levels of omega 3s and other nutrients. These nutrients come naturally from cattle allowed to live their entire lives on a pasture with no feedlot confinement,” she said. ButcherBox offers a large selection of 100% grass-fed or grass-fed, grain-finished beef, allowing customers to choose based on their meat shopping preferences. For either option, animals are never confined to a feedlot and are never given antibiotics or added hormones in their diets.

Lonsdale encourages meat shoppers to learn about animal welfare certifications,  such as Certified Humane or Animal Welfare Approved. Understanding these labels can help make purchasing beef easier, especially for those concerned about how animals were treated throughout their lifespan. However, she noted, “These certifications do not designate the diet or location where the cattle were raised.”

“There’s a lot of information out there, and it can be challenging to know if you’re making the right purchases based on your preferences,” Lonsdale explained. “Find a source you trust that shares your values. This is ButcherBox, but speaking to local butchers or providers will also offer insight into your options. A little research will go quite a long way.”

Emily Caldwell
Emily is an accomplished freelance journalist focusing on food, beverage, health, fitness, and travel content. She loves to…
Woodford Reserve launches New Distillery Series: Chocolate Whisper Redux 139.4
Woodford Reserve is launching a second Chocolate Whsiper whiskey
Woodford Reserve

Located in the heart of horse racing country in Versailles, Kentucky, Woodford Reserve is one of the biggest names in the bourbon world. It's beloved for its flagship expressions and limited-released offerings. Recently, the iconic brand announced the launch of a truly unique whiskey.
Woodford Reserve Chocolate Whisper Redux 139.4

Woodford Reserve Chocolate Whisper Redux 139.4 is a limited-edition whiskey in its Distillery Series, which was created to push the brand's innovative and creative boundaries. This new expression is also Woodford Reserve's highest-proof expression ever made. It's also the second Chocolate Whisper release, as the first one was launched in 2021.

Read more
The 10 best coffee beans to buy in 2025, chosen by coffee experts
Choosing the best coffee beans for the best tasting cup
A warm cup of coffee and spoon on a saucer with coffee beans

We all have our favorite type of coffee. Whether you prefer a dark roast coffee like I do, or something a bit lighter and more acidic like a blonde roast coffee[/internal-link], there's truly no better way to start your day than with a cup of joe. Yet, like everything in life, there’s always room for improvement.

The overwhelming number of coffee brands on the market can leave you feeling unsure which is best, which is why we're here to help with the process. After all, the best coffee beans yield the best cup of coffee. And for me, drinking the best cup of coffee puts me in the best mood. We’ve done our research to bring you our comprehensive list of the best coffee beans that will surely please your palate and elevate your mornings.

Read more
Firestone Walker teases new film on pro female surfer
A top surfer on highs, lows, and mental health
Surfer Lakey Peterson.

Firestone Walker has been dabbling in the filmmaking world as of late. The west coast brewery, via its sporty 805 Beer label, just dropped a trailer for an upcoming film it created. Titled Making Waves, the movie spotlights pro surfer Lakey Peterson and the ups and down of her remarkable career chasing waves.

A bit of a comeback story, the film touches on Peterson just missing out on the cut for the Olympic surfing team. Her inspiring resilience is on full display and currently, the seventh ranked surfer in the circuit. The Santa Barbara native, now 30, has been a pro since 2012.

Read more