Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

How to Make a Cosmopolitan Cocktail Like a Pro

Cocktail pouring in glass outdoors
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Cosmopolitan has enjoyed its ups and downs over the years. Like Merlot or fruit beers, the bright-toned cocktail is seemingly either the toast of the industry or pushed out from it entirely, depending on the year.

Two things can be blamed for the Cosmo’s damaged reputation: The 90s and a wildly popular television show. And while the drink is still recovering from the side effects, at its core it is no doubt a classic. In fact, when executed properly, the Cosmopolitan is, as the name suggests, a bit worldly and of intrigue to all kinds of drinkers, not just happy hour Manhattanites. It’s a close relative of the Sidecar and a great drink experiment with.

Recommended Videos

Related Reading

Zachery West is the bar lead at White Limozeen, the stylish rooftop bar that’s part of the Graduate Hotel in Nashville. He says the Cosmo is a product of its environment, born of a desire to create a new classic cocktail with vodka as its base. “Reaching its height of popularity in the 1990s, the Cosmopolitan has been featured time and time again on the TV show Sex and the City as a transparent purple cocktail in a V-shaped martini glass,” he says. “I think this is the most common example of how this cocktail has been misconceived. While presenting a vibrant purplish hue, if made properly, this cocktail should be cloudy in appearance and should leave your palate with notes of tart citrus as opposed to vodka and bottled cranberry juice.”

Image used with permission by copyright holder

West says the original Cosmo, from the 80s, was actually relatively complex, much more than the dumbed-down version of bottled cranberry juice and vodka we’ve grow accustomed to. The original, he says, called for things like Cointreau and fresh lime juice. “This variation elevates a boring cranberry vodka into the contemporary classic it was intended to be,” West says.

When making the best version of the cocktail, West is reminded of some sage bar advice, the old adage that your drink is only as good as its weakest ingredient. So, celebrate and embrace the nature of the Cosmo while selecting ingredients carefully. “For instance, I prefer using Clear Creek cranberry liqueur in place of a bottled cranberry juice and I also prefer using Pierre Ferrand Dry Curacao in place of Cointreau,” he says. “These small substitutions alone create a much more elevated, well balanced, and enjoyable cocktail than the stripped-down version many initially think of when they hear the word ‘Cosmopolitan.'”

Keep it classy, fellow drinkers. Cranberry juice and vodka is fine, but let’s keep that drink where it belongs, hastily whipped-up at 30,000 feet mid-flight or in the wee hours when you lack what it takes to make a real cocktail. The Cosmopolitan is iconic for a reason and ought to be made according to its original intent. You’ll end up with a better drink more indicative of its tasty roots.

Classic Cosmopolitan

There are a few original versions and they generally follow the below format. This one is heightened by both citrus vodka as well as fresh cranberry juice, which ought to be sugar-free and plenty tart to make the cocktail pop.

  • 2 ounces citrus vodka
  • .75 ounce Cointreau
  • .5 ounce fresh lime juice
  • .5 ounce pure, unsweetened cranberry juice
  • .5 ounce simple syrup
  • lime wheel for garnish

Method: Shake all ingredients with ice, then double-strain into a chilled coupe glass. Garnish with lime wheel.

Reyka Cosmo

Trevor Schneider is a brand ambassador for Reyka Vodka. The Cosmo, he says, “should be perfectly balanced between sweet and tart.” He achieves that via the below recipe.

  • 1.75 parts

    Reyka Vodka

  • .5 part Solerno Blood Orange liqueur 
  • .5 part cranberry juice
  • .5 part lime juice

Method: Combine all ingredients into cocktail shaker. Shake, strain, garnish with a lime wheel and serve.

Queen of the Rodeo

Here, West offers a riff on the Cosmo. “It’s a fun spin on this classic featuring the bright, tart notes of citrus that are very reminiscent of the original Cosmopolitan recipe with a little something extra,” he says.

  • 2 ounces of preferred vodka
  • .75 ounce lime juice
  • .75 ounce grapefruit juice
  • .5 ounce pomegranate syrup
  • .25 ounce Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur

Method: Add all ingredients to a shaker tin and mix it up. Strain into a glass, garnish with a lime wheel and dust with edible pink glitter.

Topics
Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
What cocktails to make with peanut butter whiskey
From sweet and salty to smoky and complex, here are some unusual uses for your flavored whiskey
peanut butter whiskey cocktails horizontal pbb amp j cocktail with skrewball bottle

Whilst many flavored whiskies are more suited for casual shooters than for considered sipping, there are some that have gained popularity among drinks fans. One brand that has been impressing even whiskey experts is Skrewball, a peanut butter flavored whiskey inspired by a favorite cocktail of its founders from Ocean Beach in California.

And while Skrewball is often drunk in shots, as its origin suggests it can also be used in fun cocktails. If you've picked up a bottle and are wondering what else you can make with it, we have some suggestions below. They range from the sweet and simple Peanut Butter Pretzel, which adds a few flakes of salt to balance out its sweet ingredients of peanut butter whiskey and chocolate liqueur, to the ambitious Peanut Butter Bacon & Java Martini which involves smoking your own bacon and using this to infuse your whiskey, adding savory and fatty heft to a drink when it is then married with coffee, orgeat, and bitters.

Read more
Why the (endlessly variable) Negroni should be your go-to cocktail
Ways to hack your Negroni, and bit of drink history
Negroni cocktail

The Negroni is one of the best cocktails of all time, with a simple formula of three equal parts that combine into the perfect bitter drink. With endless variations on the Negroni out there and plenty of tips on making the perfect Negroni, there's no better cocktail to make at home.
Negroni cocktail recipe

Ingredients:

Read more
Up your Tiki cocktail game by making your own Orgeat syrup
Elevate your Mai Tais and other Tiki drinks by making your own almond syrup
Orgeat Mai Tai cocktail.

Whether you're new to making Tiki drinks or you're an old hand at it with hundreds of rums in your home bar, one ingredient you'll come across over and over again when mixing Tiki cocktails is Orgeat. This almond syrup adds sweetness and nuttiness to a huge range of drinks from the Mai Tai to the Trinidad Sour, thanks to its ability to balance spirits with sweetness and to bring out the rich caramel nuttiness of fine rums.

And while it might sound like something that is complicated or difficult to make, in fact it's pretty easy to knock up your own Orgeat at home. With homemade syrup you'll enjoy a fresher taste to your cocktails, and save yourself time and effort in hunting down Orgeat in the shops as it's often hard to find commercially.
How to make Orgeat syrup
Orgeat is essentially a mix between a nut milk and a simple syrup, so you'll want to soak almonds and blend them up -- the same way you'd make nut milk -- before mixing with plenty of sugar and heating -- the same way you'd make a simple syrup. The key to making a good Orgeat is to use good quality almonds, so look for something which is unsalted, unroasted, and as fresh as you can find.

Read more