Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Grooming
  3. Best Ofs

Dr. Tusk, The Art of Shaving, Cremo, and more: Here are some of the best aftershave balms for men

Don't get burned! Get better with these soothing and healing aftershave balms

Bald man shaving face over sink
Karolina Grabowska / Pexels

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Like any of life’s pursuits, looking our best means keeping the right tools handy. If keeping your face clean-shaven is your ideal, you’ll need more than just the best razor to get an efficient shave. Your shaving regimen isn’t really complete without using one of the best aftershave balms, a critical step in keeping your skin fresh, hydrated, and in the best shape possible following a close shave. Which one is best for you? Here are a few things to think about before you start shopping for your next aftershave balm.

Shaving can overly irritate the skin, especially if you’re not careful or properly equipped. (Black men in particular can benefit from using one of these moisturizing balms — rather than a drying, alcohol-based, classic aftershave — as part of keeping skin in great shape and fighting ingrown hairs.) Use one of the aftershave balms we recommend below to deliver comfort and relief. These aftershave balms are designed to target problem areas and cool down the skin while hydrating, moisturizing, and protecting your skin, fighting the wear and tear of climate and aging. Change the way you shave by adding one of the best aftershave balms to your essential grooming products, then thank us later.

L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm 
L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm
Jump to details
Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Aftershave Balm
Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave Balm
Jump to details
Wood & Spice Aftershave
Reuzel Wood & Spice Aftershave
Jump to details
American Shaving Aftershave Balm
American Shaving Co. Aftershave Balm
Jump to details
Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm
Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm
Jump to details
Baxter of California After Shave Balm
Baxter of California After Shave Balm
Jump to details
The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm 
The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm
Jump to details
Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm 
Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm
Jump to details
Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm
Nivea Men Sensitive Soothing Post Shave Balm
Jump to details
L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm
L’Occitane

L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm

Some of the best aftershave balms get to work protecting your skin even before you start to shave — at least, that’s the case with this multi-use L’Occitane balm, which is designed to use both before and after you shave. L’Occitane’s exceptionally soothing balm helps your skin resist redness, razor burn, and feelings of tightness, plus it purifies skin to clean and soothe nicks and breakouts. Even better, the rosemary and sandalwood scent is quite delightful!

L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm 
L’Occitane Multi-Grooming Balm
Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave Balm
Pacific Shaving Company

Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave Balm

Perk up your skin after a close shave with this caffeinated aftershave balm. The naturally-derived caffeine helps reduce the appearance of redness and post-shave razor rash, plus it’s a powerful antioxidant that can help your skin repair itself and stay healthy. The balm is never tested on animals and comes in a TSA-friendly sized tube that’s perfect to slip into your suitcase so you can finish your shave the right way no matter where you end up next.

Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Aftershave Balm
Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave Balm
A close-up of a bottle of Reuzel Wood and Spice Aftershave.
Reuzel

Reuzel Wood & Spice Aftershave

Leave it to the experts at Reuzel to provide the ultimate aftershave. Use this to cool and soothe your skin after you finish shaving. This crisp and defined formula has pleasant notes of citrus and sandalwood, and this vegan formula is great for finishing off your shave in a way that tightens your pores and properly nourishes your facial and neck skin. If a wood and spice scent isn’t for you, it also comes in original scent.

Wood & Spice Aftershave
Reuzel Wood & Spice Aftershave
A close-up of a tube of Dr. Tusk Concentrated Shave Cream.
Dr. Tusk

Dr. Tusk Shave Cream

Even if you’ve already heard about Dr. Tusk’s remarkable skincare and grooming products, now’s the time to try out their amazing shave cream. Made with a plant-based proprietary blend of hemp, caffeine, and dragon’s blood (Daemonorops Draco, that is. Don’t worry. No dragons were harmed in the creation of this product.), it’s great to use before you shave, after you shave, and anytime in between. This amazing 3-in-1 shave cream will help keep your facial skin hydrated all day.

Dr. Tusk Shave Cream
Dr. Tusk Shave Cream
American Shaving Co. Aftershave Balm
American Shaving Co.

American Shaving Co. Aftershave Balm

With what the aptly named brand calls a sandalwood “barbershop” scent, we’re certain this is one of the best aftershave balms for men, as it’s expertly designed to soothe and refresh dry and irritated skin. This balm provides immediate skin hydration that lasts all day and it absorbs quickly into your skin without being greasy and it comes in a refreshing cleaan scent . We also like the fact that Amervcian Shaving Co. packs this balm in an easy-access, no mess jar.

American Shaving Aftershave Balm
American Shaving Co. Aftershave Balm
Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm
Mod Cabin

Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm

Geared toward hydration and refreshment for your skin, the ice-cold cooling sensation (what did you expect from a product named after ice?) of this aftershave balm is assuredly a welcome addition to your grooming routine. Not only does it have a very appealing alpine aroma, but it’s also highly effective at caring for your skin after shaving. With ingredients like shea butter and essential oils, this balm is perfect to be used as a moistureizer all over your face.

Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm
Mod Cabin Glacier Aftershave Balm
Rockwell Razors Aftershave Balm
Rockwell Razors

Rockwell Razors Aftershave Balm

Leave it to a brand with a focus on old-school grooming to come up with a critical addition to your shaving routine via this refined aftershave balm. Based on their many years of shaving experience, Rockwell Razors has honed in on the ideal formula to hydrate your skin, soothe irritation, and leave behind a fantastic scent. This balm includes ingredients like shea butter, coconut oil, hemp seed oil, and jojoba to nourish your skin and keep it looking and feeling healthy.

Rockwell Razors Aftershave Balm 
Rockwell Razors Aftershave Balm
Someone holds a tube of Baxter of California After Shave Balm
Baxter of California

Baxter of California After Shave Balm

Baxter of California has done it again. Now, they offer a premium aftershave that’s alcohol-free, as well as being incredibly smoothing, and even helpful in protecting your skin from visible signs of premature aging. It also works to help prevent ingrown hairs and contains glycerin to protect and hydrate skin as well as aloe vera and allantonin to soothe sensitive skin from razor burn after shaving. It comes in a menthol scent that provides a cooling sensation.

Baxter of California After Shave Balm
Baxter of California After Shave Balm
The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm
The Art of Shaving

The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm

Of course the foremost name in shaving has the ultimate moisturizer and shave balm, all rolled into one amazing formula. This aftershave balm soothes, moisturizes, and refreshes the face, helps protect from signs of aging, and won’t clog your pores. It’s also available in a travel-friendly 1 oz. tube with a soothing lavender fragrance. If lavender isn’t your cup of tea, The Art of Shaving also offers this amazing aftershave balm in sandalwood and unscented versions.

The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm 
The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm
Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm 
Cremo

Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm

This balm comes in a lightweight formula with no synthetic fragrance that soothes and moisturizes with special cooling ingredients, such as menthol and tea tree oil, leaving skin feeling clean and refreshed. Of course, Cremo’s balm also fights skin irritation and razor burn, with ingredients like shea butter, baobab seed oil, and tamanu seed oil that also hydrate skin, so we consider it a true grooming must-have. And it comes in a pleasant, refreshing mint scent.

Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm 
Cremo Cooling Post-Shave Balm

Nivea Men Sensitive Soothing Post Shave Balm

Of course, one of the leading skincare companies would make a great soothing post-shave balm for men that is especially designed for sensitive skin. This alcohol-free balm won’t dry your skin and it has ingredients like vitamin E, chamomile, and witch hazel to calm your skin after a shave, leaving it looking healthier. It keeps your skin smooth and comfortable by fighting what Nivea says are “the five signs of shave irritation: burning, micro cuts, dryness, tightness and stubble itch.” The fast-absorbing, nongreasy balm won’t feel sticky on your skin and it will provide you with long-lasting hydration.

Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm
Nivea Men Sensitive Soothing Post Shave Balm

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better: Aftershave lotion or balm?

If you ask us, the best aftershave for men is a sort of catch-all as far as soothing irritated skin is concerned, so the search for the best aftershave can often be tricky. Of course, that begs the all-important question: Is aftershave lotion or balm better for your skin? In most instances, if you do your research and dive in deep enough, you’ll discover that the best grooming products for men get the job done, be it aftershave lotion or balm.

And even if you don’t go through a targeted shaving regimen (say, if you’re one who takes great care to study up on how to shape a beard), aftershave balm or lotion can still prove highly useful.

But that being said, there’s still a debate out there, right? No doubt. Picking out aftershave lotion or balm depends on both your skin type and your personal preference. A lotion used after shaving goes on smoothly and quickly, much like your face moisturizer or face lotion, but with the targeted approach to soothe and soften irritated skin. It’s a straightforward option that works well if you already moisturize frequently (and trust us, you should certainly add that step to your grooming routine).

A balm can be more gel-like and leave a refreshing feeling, but sometimes there’s an added residue. The end-all, be-all is this: If you go with a quality product in either category (like our picks above), you can’t go wrong either way.

What does aftershave balm do?

Aftershave balm soothes and calms the skin, targeting inflammation, irritation, and nicks or cuts. The best aftershave for men works in a targeted way, giving the skin a pick-me-up of sorts. Aftershave lotions or balms specifically moisturize the skin, helping you avoid the stinging feeling that can sometimes result from shaving.

An aftershave balm is also a necessary final step in sealing in that close shave, seeing as aftershave balm is going to leave the skin soft after a close shave versus scratchy. Sometimes, the closest shave possible can leave your skin in rather rough shape.

What’s best to use after shaving?

Whether you go with lotion after shaving or an aftershave balm, options abound (as do opinions as to what’s best to use after shaving). The great news for you is that the best custom skincare brands for men often deliver a highly tailored approach that’s going to treat your skin the right way, and you’ll find a couple of them on this list.

For after shaving, we’re of the opinion that, at the end of the day, you simply need the best aftershave for men in your rotation, no questions asked. An aftershave balm can work more like a gel for your skin, targeting surface irritation, while an aftershave lotion works more deeply, akin to a face moisturizer to be used on the rest of your face. Aftershave lotion works more naturally with a grooming routine that incorporates moisturizer or face lotion, while aftershave balm often adds a refreshing, scented kick (think of old-school aftershave, but now in a modern balm form).

We hope this guide helps you find the ideal aftershave balm to add to your own personal grooming set. For more great grooming tips, take a look at this guide for the best luxury gifts for men, the best mustache waxes for better facial hair, and these helpful tips to get rid of razor burn quickly. Now that we took care of business, we’ll leave it to you to take good care of yourself.

John Jones is a Jersey City, New Jersey-based writer who enjoys covering design in all its forms, from fashion to architecture, interiors, and textiles, and has recently begun to delve into the world of social justice issues. When he’s not writing for The Manual, he’s also the Digital and Fashion Editor for a leading menswear trade publication. Although he spends most of his time planted in front of a laptop, he gets to the gym and bicycles as often as possible. On weekends and holidays, if you don’t find him at the Met, Cooper Hewitt, or Whitney museums in Manhattan, he’s probably soaking up the sun at one of Jersey’s fabulous beaches, or in St. Augustine, Florida. Send all editorial inquiries HERE. Read Full Bio
No-Shave November vs. Movember: There’s a difference between these 2 causes
The Covenant

It is November yet again. And yes, while the most important cycle you may be preparing for is the defrosting of Mariah Carey and her All I Want for Christmas domination of the airwaves, there is another you are likely hitting right now. No-Shave November is in full swing. So while all your friends are a few days into tossing their razors and trimmers away for thirty days, others are focusing on a completely separate engagement: Movember.

Most people use these two phrases interchangeably, but they are entirely different, with different origins and focuses. So what is the difference between No-Shave November and Movember? Well, sit back and let me walk you through it so you know which one you are participating in and who exactly you are supporting when you do.

Read more
Live on the Cutting Edge with expert shave advice
Cutting Edge

When a man is coming of age, there is a rite of passage he must go through. If he is lucky, he has a father who will teach him. But he must learn to shave. Whether you are a guy who loves the Harvey Specter clean-shaven look or a guy who wants to look like the wild man in the wilderness, you still need to perfect this process. Every man needs some good shaving tips. If you are a father of a son, this is a ritual you are looking forward to teaching your son. And you will cherish that moment, among others, as they move on in their life.

If you aren’t someone lucky enough to have a father or grandfather you can look to for the wisdom of the shave, then you’re the person we’re looking for here. I remember my father teaching me. So it is important to pass on the information to you. In true Mark style, I reached out to my friends at Cutting Edge and got expert information from a leader in the industry.

Read more
How The Beard Club Helped Me Grow a Beard
John Jones after beard growth

I was a failure … the facial hair equivalent of a 90-pound weakling. It wasn’t so much that I couldn’t grow a beard; it was more that whatever facial hair I did grow felt like a Velcroed-on Brillo pad: super uncomfortable and leaving my skin itchy and broken out. As Movember and No-Shave November came and went, I made two separate attempts at beard growth … each ending with a sprint into the bathroom when I could stand it no more, trimmer in hand, welcoming back the clean-shaven face I know so well. It wasn’t the first time I’d given up on hirsute happiness. 

When December rolled around, I decided to pay attention to an email I’d gotten for something called The Beard Club, a subscription service for beard care products. The Club’s premise was “helping first-timers as well as seasoned hirsute gentleman to up their grooming game.” I couldn’t resist and threw down the gauntlet. Could they help even me? After all, the site’s tag line is “Don’t Grow it Alone.”

Read more